Why does GGG always get credit for imaginary wins???

[aboutfkntime]

How do you determine a "great" win? What's the criteria?

this is why G always gets credit for imaginary wins

[Larry the boss]

oh for ****s sake.... stop it

guy has to be trolling

[TonyGe]

which one of the scrubs on G's resume, could have beaten Canelo?

name him..... ?

this will be funny

name him, Tony Baloney !!

FACT: the best win on Golovkin's resume was a HUGE underdog

think about that

Think about the fact that you can't read. I know you have a teeny tiny brain but do yourself a favor and reread what I wrote. You are embarrassing yourself. Again...

[ruedboy]

Has he defeated anyone who was even close to great?? only 5 were even world champs for crying out loud...0 hall of famers..NONE!!!! what are you celebrating is the better question

You don't get it. "Great" is a judgement. It can't be proven the way you can prove a fighter's won and loss record. A person can have an "educated" opinion or the y can be totally ignorant. Since opinions by their nature can't be proven or disproved, what's the sense of an argument that has no satisfactory ending.
I can tell you've got some strong opinions about Golovkin. if you can come up with some facts {things that can be verified) I'm happy to continue the discussion.
Ex."Floyd was great" (Opinion) "Floyd was 50-0"(Fact)

[Larry the boss]

You don't get it. "Great" is a judgement. It can't be proven the way you can prove a fighter's won and loss record. A person can have an "educated" opinion or the y can be totally ignorant. Since opinions by their nature can't be proven or disproved, what's the sense of an argument that has no satisfactory ending.
I can tell you've got some strong opinions about Golovkin. if you can come up with some facts {things that can be verified) I'm happy to continue the discussion.
Ex."Floyd was great" (Opinion) "Floyd was 50-0"(Fact)

what are these wins he has that makes his resume not trash man..he is 37 and has only defeated 5 current or former world champs..while Canelo at 28 has already defeated 15..how can you spin that?

[Larry the boss]

these are the 5 champs GGG has defeated..

Kassim Ouma, Daniel Geale, David Lemieux, Kell Brook, and Daniel Jacobs.

[ruedboy]

Has he defeated anyone who was even close to great?? only 5 were even world champs for crying out loud...0 hall of famers..NONE!!!! what are you celebrating is the better question

It's a bit tricky but I'll try to explain. "Great" is an opinion. Which means it can't be verified. There's no satisfactory conclusion to the discussion.
A quick example. "Alvarez destroyed GGG in the 2nd Fight." (Judgement)
"Alvarez won the 2nd fight by a MD." (Fact)
I don't argue opinions.

[4truth]

Jacobs without any contractual weight restrictions, the same fighter Golovkin faced, might well have given Canelo issues. We'll never know.

[aboutfkntime]

You don't get it. "Great" is a judgement. It can't be proven the way you can prove a fighter's won and loss record. A person can have an "educated" opinion or the y can be totally ignorant. Since opinions by their nature can't be proven or disproved, what's the sense of an argument that has no satisfactory ending.
I can tell you've got some strong opinions about Golovkin. if you can come up with some facts {things that can be verified) I'm happy to continue the discussion.
Ex."Floyd was great" (Opinion) "Floyd was 50-0"(Fact)

it can so

why are you so eager to ride the short-bus with the other casuals?

beating a good fighter............ is a good win
beating a very good fighter..... is a very good win
beating an excellent fighter..... is an excellent win
beating a great fighter............ is a great win

this is Golovkin's resume'.....

NOTE: I only count opponents who are better than " good "

- Jacobs *
- Murray

2x good, to very-good, wins

conclusion: Golovkin is a good, to very good, fighter

FACT: the best win on Golovkin's resume was a HUGE underdog who nobody gave a chance

FACT: the best win on Canelo's resume is a supposed killer who nobody thought he could beat

BIG diff there !!

[aboutfkntime]

these are the 5 champs GGG has defeated..

Kassim Ouma, Daniel Geale, David Lemieux, Kell Brook, and Daniel Jacobs.

two of those guys were decidedly average

one of them did not belong at middleweight

one was better than average, but then got stopped by a guy who weighed 153

Jacobs was a HUGE underdog, and nobody gave him a chance

#average