Can Demetrius Andrade's Resume Get Some More Credit? (Knowledgeable Boxing Fans Only)

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • MPDKSAB
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jan 2019
    • 1211
    • 145
    • 20
    • 50,781

    #1

    Can Demetrius Andrade's Resume Get Some More Credit? (Knowledgeable Boxing Fans Only)

    They banned your boy, thought I wasn't gon be able to make this thread, butu know I had to make my highly anticipated return. 😆

    (In all seriousness let's get down to business) No I'm not saying he has the best resume or even close. I just think some wins are better than given credit for

    His best wins are:

    Vanes
    Willie Nelson
    Alantez Fox
    Culcay




    Hard to say for sure of the order. I think styles make fights & possibly Culcay & Fox could beat Vanes. But there's a lot of intangibles I just wanna focus on these four & provide context.



    Vanes beat Willie Nelson who KO'd Tony Harrison who just beat (& I believe legitimately beat) Jermell Charlo. There were close rounds tho, I could also see a draw but I personally thought Tony won. Which means Vanes coulda been a world champion. Vanes lost a close fight to Jermell Charlo that he personally &, I've heard others maintain that he's won till this day. I personally thought Charlo won 6-4. Vanes KD Demetrius Andrade but Demetrius clearly won this fight. (& for anyone trying to pretend the SD was feasible clearly didn't watch the fight) He also beat him better than Charlo albeit he had 2 more rounds in his fight to work with. Vanes also admitted defeat to Andrade in the post fight interview of the Charlo fight but said he didn’t lose to Charlo.


    Willie Nelson as I just mentioned KO'd Tony Harrison who just beat (& I believe legitimately beat) Jermell Charlo. Which again means he also coulda been a world champion. He also beat the guy (Jackson) who was out-boxing Charlo in his vacant title win for the whole fight until he decided not to protect himself at all times & got KO'd. Albeit I didn't watch Nelson-Jackson so idk if the decision was justifiable or not but he got the win on paper. & Demetrius Andrade KO'd Nelson in a statement performance.


    Alantez Fox. I know he doesn't have any notable wins or performances even; I think, but this is definitely a fight Andrade deserves more credit for. 6'5 79 inch reach advantage, the biggest Middleweight recorded in history until proven otherwise at this point. Andrade fought him in his 1st fight in this weight class. Fox had every physical advantage going in. Andrade only rehydrated to 167 btw. I don't think you can name me 1 fighter (who doesn't hold an IBF belt) that rehydrates under 10lbs after the weigh-in. & mind you that's only the morning after for IBF belt holders. Meaning they exceed that 10lb weight by the time they actually fight. I don't think people understand. & For those who don't understand how boxing/matchmaking works, that's not a fight you want someone (in this case Andrade) taking while they're on the cusp of bigger fights. Or if you're building a star that's not a fight you give them until the risk is worth the reward. GBP would have never put 21-24 yr old Canelo in with 23-27 yr old amateur standout Demetrius Andrade. Shlt you see how Lara had to go about getting the Canelo fight. Fox is someone (like Andrade) that you don't fight if you don't have to. Fox needs to prove himself before fighting the current belt holders of the division but ask yourself do you think Lemeiux, Murata, or BJS would fight him? See my point. Shlt Fox even claims Ronnie Shields doesn't want Charlo to fight him:



    I personally think Charlo would KO him so I take this with a grain of salt. BUT this also isn't the 1st time something like this has been claimed of Charlo/Shields:



    Ronnie Shields has denied this ☝ but you be the judge of what you believe. Two different sources saying similar things. But I say all that to say this Andrade deserves more credit for fighting the biggest Middleweight in history in his 1st fight in the division point blank period.



    Culcay. I think Andrade had his worst notable performance in this fight, but he still won clearly. Culcay is fresh off going life & death with Derevyanchenko. Derevyanchenko is revered amongst "hardcores." I understand why GGG didn't want to fight him from a match up standpoint but I also think Sergiy is overrated. Haters of Andrade were claiming Andrade ducked Sergiy. I know styles make fights but we can clearly see Andrade not even on his best night in Germany beat him better than Derevyanchenko beat him. I'm sure there's people who believe Culcay beat Sergiy btw. Also.. people are saying Andrade's next opponent Sulecki is the best of his career. I never seen the Culcay-Sulecki fight. But I've heard murmurs of people believing Culcay won that as well.

    All in all I just wanted to provide context that Andrade's resume deserves a lil more credit than it has. I wonder what people will say if he dominates Sulecki? 🤔
  • kushking
    Osiris the pssy vampire
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Sep 2013
    • 9520
    • 891
    • 2,019
    • 337,046

    #2
    Originally posted by MPDKSAB
    ..........
    You make some good pts & I am happy hes now stepping up trying to build his resume vs Sulecki whos a decent fighter.

    I want the winner of his next fight to face Canelo because I think hes currently the most deserving of the nelo sweepstakes for the simple fact that he has the last belt for undisputed regardless of him getting it from a amatuer & nobody can deny hes legitimately been trying to get big fights( even though he ducked charlo imho) he was blatantly ducked by billyhoe saunders,& hes a big guy who might make it interesting vs Canelo. Simply put out of Canelos next possible opponents he makes the most sense,even though I wouldn't mind him facing ggg again afterwards ONLY if ggg stops ducking EVERYONE

    Comment

    • MPDKSAB
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Jan 2019
      • 1211
      • 145
      • 20
      • 50,781

      #3
      Bumping this up where are the knowledgeable boxing fans at to chime in on this?
      Originally posted by kushking
      You make some good pts & I am happy hes now stepping up trying to build his resume vs Sulecki whos a decent fighter.

      I want the winner of his next fight to face Canelo because I think hes currently the most deserving of the nelo sweepstakes for the simple fact that he has the last belt for undisputed regardless of him getting it from a amatuer & nobody can deny hes legitimately been trying to get big fights( even though he ducked charlo imho) he was blatantly ducked by billyhoe saunders,& hes a big guy who might make it interesting vs Canelo. Simply put out of Canelos next possible opponents he makes the most sense,even though I wouldn't mind him facing ggg again afterwards ONLY if ggg stops ducking EVERYONE
      That might've changed after the WBC's ruling. Who knows now if Canelo & Andrade would really be undisputed?....

      Comment

      • Nehnenqui
        Banned
        Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
        • Mar 2019
        • 463
        • 37
        • 1
        • 13,351

        #4
        Yes, Andrade has a better resume than Canelo! Canelo needs to stop ducking!

        LDBC x PBC Gang in dis thang mayne!

        Comment

        • SplitSecond
          Undisputed Champion
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Nov 2009
          • 23151
          • 1,715
          • 1,187
          • 85,044

          #5
          Disgusting. Gtfo. Only good win there is Vanes.

          Comment

          • MPDKSAB
            Undisputed Champion
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Jan 2019
            • 1211
            • 145
            • 20
            • 50,781

            #6
            Originally posted by Nehnenqui
            Yes, Andrade has a better resume than Canelo! Canelo needs to stop ducking!

            LDBC x PBC Gang in dis thang mayne!
            I asked you not to come in my thread.
            Originally posted by SplitSecond
            Disgusting. Gtfo. Only good win there is Vanes.
            Explain.

            Comment

            • Htown-Finest
              Undisputed Champion
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Jun 2019
              • 1008
              • 15
              • 103
              • 16,519

              #7
              Hardcore fans respect Andrade. He’s been wanting the fights.

              But what more to say...................................... nothing.
              Kinda his fault for signing with an amateur promoter then I believe resigning.

              Now we wait and see with DAZN. I feel for Bud Crawford. But damn he resigned

              Comment

              • Boxing_1013
                Undisputed Champion
                Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                • Feb 2019
                • 6845
                • 184
                • 256
                • 157,917

                #8
                You said you were gonna make this thread so I am glad I came across it...good to see a boxing talk thread on here, I like it.

                My thoughts:
                I think you make a good point about Nelson...he has a MD loss early in his career...so who knows what happened there...and that win over Harrison looks pretty good right now...his only two other losses are to Vanes and Andrade, and Andrade stopped him...albeit in the 12th round...but a pretty good win.

                That win looks a little better...just like how the 160 Charlo's win over JRock is looking better now too...though not quite as good imo, but close...they both soundly beat a guy who had/would beat 'the guy'...as you mentioned the Fox win is hard to rate right now, because he hasn't faced anyone else besides Andrade...I don't recognize another name on Fox's resume right now...doesn't seem to have a ton of power either, so not sure what his future really is...but we will have to see about that one...that one is a TBD for me and I don't know a ton about him.

                I never watched the Vanes fight from 1-12 and scored it...so I have no opinion on the score...the KD is a bit of disappointment in that fight, but it happens...I guess I would have liked to have seen a stoppage from Andrade over Vanes to really get excited about him there, especially after the KD...but that isn't really Andrade's game...general consensus here is that Andrade deserved to win the fight so that is a good win...but would have liked him to do more there.

                Culcay is a good fighter...now we know that, but we didn't really know it at that time...not a tremendously impressive win for Andrade considering he didn't exactly dominate there...I also have never watched that from 1-12 so can't give my opinion on it in total...but Culcay has looked good against Dervy...I thought Culcay was the better man, draw was fine imo...Dervy winning was not really what I saw...never watched him vs Sulecki so I can't comment...most seem to think it was competitive and a close fight.

                Just seems like Andrade has fought 3 guys now who we kind of know their level...he got the job done vs Vanes, Culcay and Nelson, but maybe wasn't as impressive as he wanted to be...Sulecki will be the 4th guy he faces who we know what he is/has...if Andrade can impress against him I think it will be a really good win...and would put him right up there with anyone at MW...if I watch it and score it 7-5 or worse for him I will be a little cautious of whether or not the hype meets the results...good news for him is it is all in his hands.

                I'm really excited for it and am probably leaning 60/40 Andrade right now...think he may win 8-4 but wouldn't be surprised to see a 6-6 or so fight either...can't wait to see it

                Comment

                • MPDKSAB
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Jan 2019
                  • 1211
                  • 145
                  • 20
                  • 50,781

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Htown-Finest
                  Hardcore fans respect Andrade. He’s been wanting the fights.

                  But what more to say...................................... nothing.
                  Kinda his fault for signing with an amateur promoter then I believe resigning.

                  Now we wait and see with DAZN. I feel for Bud Crawford. But damn he resigned
                  This thread is about his resume tho, do you feel it's better, worse, or accurate among the general consensus?
                  Originally posted by Boxing1013
                  You said you were gonna make this thread so I am glad I came across it...good to see a boxing talk thread on here, I like it.

                  My thoughts:
                  I think you make a good point about Nelson...he has a MD loss early in his career...so who knows what happened there...and that win over Harrison looks pretty good right now...his only two other losses are to Vanes and Andrade, and Andrade stopped him...albeit in the 12th round...but a pretty good win.

                  That win looks a little better...just like how the 160 Charlo's win over JRock is looking better now too...though not quite as good imo, but close...they both soundly beat a guy who had/would beat 'the guy'...as you mentioned the Fox win is hard to rate right now, because he hasn't faced anyone else besides Andrade...I don't recognize another name on Fox's resume right now...doesn't seem to have a ton of power either, so not sure what his future really is...but we will have to see about that one...that one is a TBD for me and I don't know a ton about him.

                  I never watched the Vanes fight from 1-12 and scored it...so I have no opinion on the score...the KD is a bit of disappointment in that fight, but it happens...I guess I would have liked to have seen a stoppage from Andrade over Vanes to really get excited about him there, especially after the KD...but that isn't really Andrade's game...general consensus here is that Andrade deserved to win the fight so that is a good win...but would have liked him to do more there.

                  Culcay is a good fighter...now we know that, but we didn't really know it at that time...not a tremendously impressive win for Andrade considering he didn't exactly dominate there...I also have never watched that from 1-12 so can't give my opinion on it in total...but Culcay has looked good against Dervy...I thought Culcay was the better man, draw was fine imo...Dervy winning was not really what I saw...never watched him vs Sulecki so I can't comment...most seem to think it was competitive and a close fight.

                  Just seems like Andrade has fought 3 guys now who we kind of know their level...he got the job done vs Vanes, Culcay and Nelson, but maybe wasn't as impressive as he wanted to be...Sulecki will be the 4th guy he faces who we know what he is/has...if Andrade can impress against him I think it will be a really good win...and would put him right up there with anyone at MW...if I watch it and score it 7-5 or worse for him I will be a little cautious of whether or not the hype meets the results...good news for him is it is all in his hands.

                  I'm really excited for it and am probably leaning 60/40 Andrade right now...think he may win 8-4 but wouldn't be surprised to see a 6-6 or so fight either...can't wait to see it
                  I always thought Charlo's win over J rock was under appreciated. It's one of those were people question if you can beat him, then after you do they literally say he was nobody anyway. Because that's what happened. J rock has good skills. If you actually go back & look at the betting lines it was 50-50 as it gets. Boxing fans are fickle tho. 1 loss don't make you a bad fighter & J rock spoke on that after his Hurd win. I always gave him credit for the win especially because I thought J rock was gonna beat him. But at the time people were accusing Jermall of ducking J rock. He was struggling to make weight, wanted to leave 154, & almost didn't make weight to even defend the belt that last time.

                  Regardless Fox is still not an easy fight for the intangibles I spoke about. I think Fox is an avoided fighter by the people who are trying to be elite like himself. Nobodys gonna wanna fight a 6'5 Middleweight.

                  I think Culcay's performance against Andrade had more to do with Andrade than what Culcay was doing. I always maintained that since I saw it. From about round 5 or 6 Andrade was winning, but I said to myself this isn't the Andrade I'm used to seeing & Culcay did nothing, it's not like he was neutralizing, it was just Andrade wasn't his normal self. Come to find out later he was sick in Germany.

                  Now with Andrade's latest performance. You can see he's the truth like I told you. 😏😏

                  Comment

                  • Mammoth
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Sep 2016
                    • 35717
                    • 3,848
                    • 3,389
                    • 378,304

                    #10
                    Vanes was a legit win at the time.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP