Castillo-floyd 1 or maidana-floyd 1? Which robbery is worse?

[4truth]

I thought the Castillo fight was a bad decision bordering on robbery. I thought for a guy basically shutout be Devon Alexander, Maidana made the fight with Floyd surprisingly close but I thought Floyd won.

[Pantera_]

I had Castillo winning too but I wouldnt say an all out robbery. Just a bad decision.

Mayweather beat Maidana in my opinion close but clear. The whole glove thing probably helped Mayweather a little bit though.

[pasawayako]

Fcking losers...Castillio only person to beat Floyd and it was still close.

Pathetic in 2019

Nope. not only castillo. Maidana, pac and he has a very very close fight with dela Hoya that even his own father thinks that dela hoya won the fight.

[Redd Foxx]

I don't know what's sadder, still being obsessed with Floyd after all the years, or thinking Maidana beat him. Both are pretty pathetic.

What confuses me is that it's super easy to trash Floyd when you look at him being a convicted woman beater. But, these guys choose the ******est arguments that no one who knows anything about boxing believes. Like Maidana beating him.

[hugh grant]

I

Castillo for sure, I don't think Maidana won.

Boxing fans probably think Castillo win was more convincing.
Casual observers, for example say casual watchers of sport with boxing, with boxing not being favourite sport , or if your gran was watching they would think Ma diana was beating Floyd up and leave poor lil Floyd alone someone stop Floyd taking so much punishment

[FinitoxDinamita]

Yeah. The embarrassing part is that both fighter is like class B at best.

Castillo is B level?? Cmon dude lol

Perhaps Maidana is a glorified B class but Castillo is on a whole different stratosphere.

[nubianpiye]

I have to say Castillo. Castillo makes floyd look like a garbage and dominate him in every department.

Your mother robbing the semem from my nut sack was worse son.

[JERMELL_CHARLO_]

I have to say Castillo. Castillo makes floyd look like a garbage and dominate him in every department.

Castillo kicked Fraud Cherrypicker's ass so Jose Luis gets my vote!

[D4thincarnation]

Maidana.

Because Fraud forced Maidana to wear pillow and still got his ass beat and crying for the ref for protection.

In the second fight Fraud got him to wear pillows again and then got his own ref in to stop Maidana punching him when he got too rough for Fraud.


Castillo did dominate Fraud too though.

[pasawayako]

I don't know what's sadder, still being obsessed with Floyd after all the years, or thinking Maidana beat him. Both are pretty pathetic.

What confuses me is that it's super easy to trash Floyd when you look at him being a convicted woman beater. But, these guys choose the ******est arguments that no one who knows anything about boxing believes. Like Maidana beating him.

Yeah it's pathetic because you couldnt accept that other people has different opinion and isn't bias. If u think floyd beat them then that's your opinion but majority of people thinks different.