Better resume: Naoya Inoue or "Gallo" Estrada?

[sicko]

Estrada of course! I would love to see that fight eventually

[pillowfists98]

Inoue. He has the overall better resume.

[DuckAdonis]

Estrada:
Rungvisai
Cuadras
Close fight with Roman Gonzalez
Brian Viloria
Undefeated Milan Melindo

Inoue:
Emmanuel Rodriguez
McDonnell
Payano
Narvaez
Taguchi


Im taking Estrada but Inoue's is not bad. Especially when you consider how he beat his competition

[Aztekkas]

Inoue. He has the overall better resume.

How so? Estrada has an incredibly deep resume.


From Sanchez Jr., to Viloria, Melindo, Marquez, Segura, Cuadras and of course Wangek/Sor Rungvisai. Those names are all on par or notches above Naoya's best wins.

[thecomedian2]

No he didn't. By the time Inoue reached championship level, Chocolatitos days at 108 were over.

Let's all forget that Inoue Jumped weight divisions to duck the Sharks at the Tank from 112-115, when the 115 got hot too he jumped to 118.

[thecomedian2]

How so? Estrada has an incredibly deep resume.

Don't even debate with that Troll.

To say Inou has a better resume than Estrada just shows how ignorant he is!

[just the facts]

Let's all forget that Inoue Jumped weight divisions to duck the Sharks at the Tank from 112-115, when the 115 got hot too he jumped to 118.

Okay all that might be true. But claiming Inoue ducked Chocalatito at 108 (as you posted) is just plain not true.

[thecomedian2]

Okay all that might be true. But claiming Inoue ducked Chocalatito at 108 (as you posted) is just plain not true.

not at 108... But he did said a few times that he was not ready for Chocolatito when asked about it.

[techliam]

If he beats 36-year-old Donaire would you vault him above Estrada on the P4P lists?

Yes, if he beats him in the fashion I outlined.

Estrada hasn’t really done a great deal in the past couple of years. Yes he beat Rungvisai, but he also lost to him recently. He needs another good win to prove it wasn’t just a demotivated Rungvisai, because there are some signs in that fight

[Mexican_Puppet]

Nery fights at 122. There are rules, in order to be the best at 118, you have to actually weigh 118 or less.

Inoue vs Estrada. Who wins?

Last fight of Nery was in 118 and he looked very strong and destroyed brutally Arroyo .

Estrada by D.U, the hype of Inoue is insane, but Estrada is fighting in 115 and he does not have any fight with a good rival in bantamweight.

He will clean the 115, at that time Inoue will be fighting in 122.

Nery will K.O Inoue too.