Better resume: Naoya Inoue or "Gallo" Estrada?

[Santa_]

Donnie Nietes > both but as for the poll I'd say Gallito has the better resume than Naoya.

[Mexican_Puppet]

Most would agree that a 36 yr old past prime Donaire will be Inoue's toughest opponent so far in his career. That speaks for itself. In my eyes he hasn't been tested, and for that reason I cannot rate him above fighters who have.



My whole point is we should be giving fighters like Canelo and GGG more credit for fighting each other, instead of rewarding fighters who haven't stepped up to the plate and ranking them above fighters who have taken on a real challenge. All based on the "eye test".

And btw, very few people are calling Canelo p4p #1 even after he tamed GGG in that first fight and broke his face in the 2nd.

Great post

Just the truth

[Mexican_Puppet]

Surprise, the guy with over 40 fights has a better resume than the guy with less than 20.

Thats a excuse

When Estrada was 23 years old he fought with Román González in 108 and then he fought with Viloria in 112.

Viloria was at least in a top-15 P4P list.

Inoue resume is trash

[Squ□redCircle34]

****** thread, Estrada has him beat by a mile and he would also take Inoue to school as well!

Unlike Inoue’s opposition, Estrada wouldn’t stand in front of him stiff like a statue and trade with him, he would give him angles, work the jab, and counter Inoue’s body shots with left hooks to the head and a right hand to the grill!

Estrada would be the smartest and best opponent Inoue has ever fought!

[ShoulderRoll]

Inoue is now #2 on BoxingScene's P4P list.

[ShoulderRoll]

https://www.boxingscene.com/forums/view.php?pg=pound

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Estrada and it is isn’t even close.

[ShoulderRoll]

Estrada and it is isn’t even close.

I completely agree.

[JERMELL_CHARLO_]

El Gallo Estrada.

[BoloShot]

Inoue's only getting started on fighting all the top names at 118 so I'd give a wait on that vote for a few months at the very least and then we'd have more debatable results.