Do any NON-Mexicans actually rate Canelo?

[Armchairhero]

At least he’s fought all the big names at each weight, how we can have P4P who don’t fight anyone is beyond me

That being said he hasn’t had a convincing win against his last few big fights, if Danny started from round one and fought for centre ring he’d of won no doubts about it.

[Curtis Harper]

I do

Has to be p4p king.

[Ca$ual Fan]

That is actually what I was trying to point out earlier in the other thread.

People keep clamoring about his resume but the good wins in his resume have asterisks in most of them. I respect that he took challenges and win them, but if you want to be undoubtedly ranked as the "the best", you have to establish DOMINANCE too - that's where Canelo lacks at this point. You can say he's one the bests but he's not a standout and it's very disputable.

He's just a tiptop 1st in a strong competition, which can easily be overtaken.

[elfag]

Canelo has the best resume by far today. Its not even close.

The only guy who matches him is pacquaio and hes almost retired.

[MDPopescu]

Do any NON-Mexicans actually rate Canelo?

Like seriously, he's a good fighter, but he lost to GGG twice and I'm not even sure he won tonight (but was close).

I can't believe the amount of either one-eyed or bias people on here...I'd love to see him actually win a fight clearly, but until now I haven't and that's when I can't rate a fighter in the top of any rankings... yet I see ppl writing about his "resume" and him being a P4P fighter, FML am I drunk or am I just dumb.

His best wins are against Liam Smith, Amir Khan, Rocky Who? Fielding and James Kirkland, just about every other "win" was not a win!

I rate Canelo as the "biggest star in boxing to date"...
... but not as the P4P #1...

... (my candidates for P4P #1 are Crawford, Loma, Spence, Usyk...)

[moochi]

He is starting to remind me a lot of Sven Ottke... all of them *wins* at home with all the favoritism. Nothing special about him!

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Like seriously, he's a good fighter, but he lost to GGG twice and I'm not even sure he won tonight (but was close).

I can't believe the amount of either one-eyed or bias people on here...I'd love to see him actually win a fight clearly, but until now I haven't and that's when I can't rate a fighter in the top of any rankings... yet I see ppl writing about his "resume" and him being a P4P fighter, FML am I drunk or am I just dumb.

His best wins are against Liam Smith, Amir Khan, Rocky Who? Fielding and James Kirkland, just about every other "win" was not a win!

Yes! He’s an excellent fighter. P4P top 5 IMO. Canelo fanboys overrate him but there’s no denying his talent.

And that’s coming from a huge GGG fan who doesn’t
like Canelo and his entitled fan base whatsoever.

[moochi]

Yes! He’s an excellent fighter. P4P top 5 IMO. Canelo fanboys overrate him but there’s no denying his talent.

And that’s coming from a huge GGG fan who doesn’t
like Canelo and his entitled fan base whatsoever.

Dunno dude, when I say "rate" i mean as being great and P4P.

On your logic, do you also have Keith Thurman in your top P4P list?

[Aztekkas]

Like seriously, he's a good fighter, but he lost to GGG twice and I'm not even sure he won tonight (but was close).

I can't believe the amount of either one-eyed or bias people on here...I'd love to see him actually win a fight clearly, but until now I haven't and that's when I can't rate a fighter in the top of any rankings... yet I see ppl writing about his "resume" and him being a P4P fighter, FML am I drunk or am I just dumb.

His best wins are against Liam Smith, Amir Khan, Rocky Who? Fielding and James Kirkland, just about every other "win" was not a win!

Didn't know Ring Magazine and tons of other press and well known boxing outlets that rate him highly were a bunch of Mexicans.

[SweetPbfAli]

Canelo is legit. He's done some things I'm not a fan of such as the PED thing and his own temporary weight class of 155 but he's a fighter through and through and a damn good one.