Comments Thread For: BoxingScene Pound for Pound: April 2019 Update

[BIGPOPPAPUMP]

If one entered the last two weekends with Terence Crawford and Vasyl Lomachenko as their leaders in the field of mythological wonders where all fighters might compete at the same size, nothing happened against Amir Khan or Anthony Crolla, respectively, to change that.
[Click Here To Read More]

[Jax teller]

How is Mikey No. 9 after declaring himself too big for 135 and demonstrating that he is not going to be effecive with the top guys at 147? Not hating but it doesn't seem that logical.

[Pennsauken1]

That is a fraud list, where is Wilder, AJ, and Tank at?

[P4Pdunny]

That is a fraud list, where is Wilder, AJ, and Tank at?

I like all three but who would you have them in place of?

[1hourRun]

I disagree with Mr. Rold, I feel that Errol Spence Jr. should be demoted after his pitiful performance vs. Mickey.

Terence displayed a masterful boxing exhibition against a man his own size, effortlessly dominating his rival like a true elite.

[Removed Now]

That is a fraud list, where is Wilder, AJ, and Tank at?

Historically they never included heavyweights on the P4P list.

[Removed Now]

Can somebody please run down Crawford last 4 victories and tell me why he should be number 1??!??!

[Bjl12]

I disagree with Mr. Rold, I feel that Errol Spence Jr. should be demoted after his pitiful performance vs. Mickey.

Terence displayed a masterful boxing exhibition against a man his own size, effortlessly dominating his rival like a true elite.

Completely agree. Spencer is a fringe Top 10 fighter if we're being honest. He couldn't legitimately hurt a LIGHTWEIGHT while Terrence won every round and literally forced a WELTERWEIGHT to quit.

Anyhow the list in general is "okay".

Spence and GGG are too high with both being 9 or 10 on my list.

Anthony Joshua shined against a true elite ATG HW in Klitschko while GGG struggled with Danny J and Canelo...yet Gggirl is #7 and AJ is undefeated and dominant but unranked?

Errald Spencer best win is against Kell Brook whom everyone basically laughs at now...the same Kell Brook who jumped up then down 2 weight classes, suffered first loss a TKO, and needed reconstructive surgery...and Errald was 4-4 after 8 rounds with THAT fighter who GASSED...which is what happens when you go up/down 1 - let alone TWO - weight classes. Yet Errald is #5 for abusing a LW and AJ is unranked???

The PBC bias is in full effect with Wilder and Charlo listed "for the future". Wilfer is 32 and Charlo is 29. When is that future? Lmfaooooo

Rold, you are a punk made pus.sy

[1hourRun]

Completely agree. Spencer is a fringe Top 10 fighter if we're being honest. He couldn't legitimately hurt a LIGHTWEIGHT while Terrence won every round and literally forced a WELTERWEIGHT to quit.

Anyhow the list in general is "okay".

Spence and GGG are too high with both being 9 or 10 on my list.

The PBC bias is in full effect with Wilder and Charlo listed "for the future". Wilfer is 32 and Charlo is 29. When is that future? Lmfaooooo

Good lord! was Golovkin mentioned?! How dreadful.

[ruedboy]

Canelo's latest wins include the cream of British boxing such as Rocky Fielding, Beefy Smith. and King Khan.
The Mexican truly is the British Destroyer (and poacher of paper titles).