Does this change your P4P #1 outlook at all?

[deanrw]

You could pick either guy really. Loma and Crawford both are on that next level stuff as far as skills go. Their tool boxes are deep.

[Nehnenqui]

Nothing changes for me. We’ll start to see changes in the next 2 weeks with Estrada vs. SSR and Canelo vs. Jacobs. If Estrada KOs SSR then I’ll put him in Inoue’s spot. If he decisions him he stays at 5 and if he loses he goes down a few spots and SSR enters the top 10. If Canelo KOs Jacobs he obviously stays in the top spot and nobody would be close to him. If Jacobs upsets Canelo then he would go way up and Canelo would drop down behind Spence, Crawford, Inoue, and Jacobs.

1. Canelo
2. Spence
3. Crawford
4. Inoue
5. Estrada
6. Usyk
7. Nietes
8. M. Garcia
9. Jacobs
10. Joshua

[dan_cov]

Nothing changes for me. We’ll start to see changes in the next 2 weeks with Estrada vs. SSR and Canelo vs. Jacobs. If Estrada KOs SSR then I’ll put him in Inoue’s spot. If he decisions him he stays at 5 and if he loses he goes down a few spots and SSR enters the top 10. If Canelo KOs Jacobs he obviously stays in the top spot and nobody would be close to him. If Jacobs upsets Canelo then he would go way up and Canelo would drop down behind Spence, Crawford, Inoue, and Jacobs.

1. Canelo
2. Spence
3. Crawford
4. Inoue
5. Estrada
6. Usyk
7. Nietes
8. M. Garcia
9. Jacobs
10. Joshua

Inoue #4, why?
Inoue above Usyk, Estrada etc based on what?
Certainly not skills, resume or absolutely anything boxing related surely

[BoxingFan85]

Loma or Crawford, I can see no problem in both being #1 or one over the other.

[Curtis Harper]

Bud vs Khan was like a major league team (Bud) playing against it's AA league affiliate (Khan). It is a rout before the game even started.

[KTFOKING]

Khan is just a name at this point. You can even say Crawford should have koed him inside four.

I mean Crawford isn't a huge puncher so I didn't expect him to get a KO within four rounds. But Khan is definitely a fighter who is closer to being shot than in his prime. His reaction time is gone and his legs are not what they once more. I mean he still landed some clean shots and I thought late 5th round and even in the 6th round, he may have landed his best shots of the fight lol.

Nothing Crawford/Lomachenko did in the past week should sway anyone's opinions. Both were in huge mismatches and did what they were supposed to do.

[DaNeutral.]

I have them both the same as I did two weeks ago. Both fights went how I expected. Crolla is a C level domestic guy, and Khan has been shot for a while.

Now looking ahead at Loma/Comney and Crawford/Spence (hoping both are next) Those will be a far better gauge.

This really for me. Loma and Bud are 2 very different style of fighters but i struggle to split them at the top of the P4P rankings and neither of their most recent fights have changed my opinions on it. Those fights were not career defining fights, they were not big tests and the outcomes were pretty much inevitable.

Also looking ahead i totally agree about those fights being a better and truer gauge or their positioning.

So yeah, what he said.

[W1LL]

No. I don't really see it as an argument. Lomachenko is #1, nobody comes close. If Crawford could beat Spence emphatically, then we could talk.

[Eff Pandas]

Nope. I still think P4P is boxing dork scifi fantasy bs.

[WhatDisButtonDo]

Lomachenko and Crawford imo are the two most complete fighters on the planet. I think Crawford is a slightly better fighter. He has extremely high ring IQ just like loma, but p4p has superior physical attributes such as punching power, reach(on a p4p basis), stronger for his division and a better in fighter.