Which victory was more impressive against overmatched opponents?

[dibzvincent143]

None were impressive but only one guy cheated on the scales.

I agree to some extent that we shouldn’t be impressed with fighters winning against guys two weight classes below them.

But in this case were comparing the awful matchups so im sure there’s a winner

[dibzvincent143]

The bold alone should make that a negative, but to each their own

Fighting guys two weight classes below you is already a negative. So in this case were comparing the negatives and there will be winner

I hate the marquez victory the way it happened, as many other welterweights were calling out Floyd plus sergio martinez. Then cheating on the scales. But in this case, it’s atleast more impressive than the other two that fought guys two weight classes below them.

Had spence KOd garcia then it’d be the top 1

[dan_cov]

Floyds win over Marquez then Loma's over Rigo.
Spence beating Mikey was just meh, way less significant than even GGG beating Brook.

[mcdonalds]

Floyd easily. He was coming off a 2 year layoff

[dibzvincent143]

Floyds win over Marquez then Loma's over Rigo.
Spence beating Mikey was just meh, way less significant than even GGG beating Brook.

Oh i forgot to include GGG’s.
Or Canelo-khan

[HarvardBlue]

Loma's victory,
Nobody had solved the Rigo defence wizard puzzle yet, and it was done is style, no mas.
Marquez had allready been beat.

Rigondeaux had been knocked down a few times before including by a low level opponents. The riddle wasn't that hard to solve.