PRIME Floyd Mayweather vs PRIME Manny Pacquiao, Who would win and how?

[Bjl12]

Another impressive fact, Canelo had competitive fights and possibly won against GGG
And Floyd made canelo look like an amateur (although he was still young that time)

Well Canelo did win against GGG and drew in their first fight. Nonetheless styles make fights.

Canelo's success against GGG and Floyd's success against Canelo do not mean Floyd beats GGG (although I think he would've especially at 154).

[daggum]

will floyd be pumped full of iv fluid? to clean up his system i mean boxing. you want to talk about ggg feather jabs watch floyd-pac! tickle your nose!

[pasawayako]

Is this kid serious?

Floyd fought JMM in 2009 at 147. Pac fought JMM in 2011 and 2012 at 147 (as well as in 2004 and 2008).

Floyd fought a fresher JMM in 2009 which is when Pac was given a highly controversial *win* while many called it a ROBBERY. Floyd shutout that JMM

The problem with Pac fans is they lack objectivity.

Manny beat DLH, Mosley, Hatton, and Cotto better than Floyd, however, Floyd fought better versions of DLH, Mosley, and Hatton. Nonetheless Manny beat them all better.

Floyd beat JMM more decisively than Manny ever did and was never KD or KTFO.

When they finally fought Floyd won a very uneventful decision.

What's confusing?

Now you're saying floyd fought a fresher JMM??? hahhahaaahaha.

[Curtis Harper]

Imho, its May. Prime May, PRIOR to his move to ww, was a very dangerous fighter. He didn't rely on is boxing abilities. No one had a natural size advantage over him. Prime Pac was pretty predictable, movement wise.

Prime May would probably TKO prime Pac.

[Roadblock]

Now you're saying floyd fought a fresher JMM??? hahhahaaahaha.

He treated the same JMM that nearly killed Manny like an amateur that looked like he had no right to be in the ring with him, the difference in class was massive.

You poor kid you have no idea what youre looking at.

[Curtis Harper]

He treated the same JMM that nearly killed Manny like an amateur that looked like he had no right to be in the ring with him, the difference in class was massive.

You poor kid you have no idea what youre looking at.

This is true.

An older JMM nearly killed Pac.

No version of JMM comes close to doing that to May.

[Bjl12]

Is this kid serious?

Floyd fought JMM in 2009 at 147. Pac fought JMM in 2011 and 2012 at 147 (as well as in 2004 and 2008).

Floyd fought a fresher JMM in 2009 which is when Pac was given a highly controversial *win* while many called it a ROBBERY. Floyd shutout that JMM

The problem with Pac fans is they lack objectivity.

Manny beat DLH, Mosley, Hatton, and Cotto better than Floyd, however, Floyd fought better versions of DLH, Mosley, and Hatton. Nonetheless Manny beat them all better.

Floyd beat JMM more decisively than Manny ever did and was never KD or KTFO.

When they finally fought Floyd won a very uneventful decision.

What's confusing?

Now you're saying floyd fought a fresher JMM??? hahhahaaahaha.

Ya I mean there's not really any debate about that lol

If you want to argue the weight of the fight was unfair than you can argue that, but Floyd fought a fresher version of JMM than Pac did in 3rd and 4th fights.

You'd be hard-pressed to find someone who says Floyd won because of weight. Styles make fights.

[Raonic]

But he signed a 50/50 contract to fight him.


It's time everyone stops with this myth. Even Freddie Roach admits it was their side that stopped the fight from happening in 2010.

Why can't it both sides at fault?

[D4thincarnation]

Pacquiao wins, there was a reason why Floyd ducked the fight for 6 years.

Floyd knew he would lose and wanted to run a few extra PED cycles.

Waited for Pacquiao to slow down and get KOed and lose then only felt brave enough with the ref of his choice and a shoulder injury from Pacquiao, and even then still ran and touched jabbed all fight and hugged Pacquiao whenever he got in ranged.

Lucky Floyd had the ref in his pocket.

[travestyny]

Why can't it both sides at fault?

It could certainly be both sides at fault.

I suppose you could blame Mayweather for wanting to ensure an even playing field, but that seems off to me.