Comments Thread For: Roach Says a Prime Pacquiao 'Walks Through' Everyone at 147

[Fangedgrowl]

I think Pac beats Thurmon. I cant get that image of Collazo or Quintana wgich ever one it was landing that body shot on Keith and he retreating fast. Plus Keith really struggled with Poret and Garcia.

I think Pac's toughest fight would be Crawford for some reason, then Mayweather 2 , then Spence. Spence is big and tough, but i could see Pac stinging him often with shots as he pulled back from throwing Power shots.

[Fangedgrowl]

I think Pac's toughest fight would be Crawford for some reason, then Mayweather 2 , then Spence. Spence is big and tough, but i could see Pac stinging him often with shots as he pulled back from throwing Power shots.

Porter, wow terrible typing skills today from me.

[The Big Dunn]

I think Pac beats Thurmon. I cant get that image of Collazo or Quintana wgich ever one it was landing that body shot on Keith and he retreating fast. Plus Keith really struggled with Poret and Garcia.

Fair points. I disagree but he didn't dominate them. Although, as much as I like Danny, I thought he beat Danny clearly and Danny was delusional thinking it was close.

[Fangedgrowl]

Fair points. I disagree but he didn't dominate them. Although, as much as I like Danny, I thought he beat Danny clearly and Danny was delusional thinking it was close.

Would love to see Pac- Spence just for the action and Crawford- Thurmon if dude would ever come back. Winners fight!

[IceTrayDaGang]

They only both fought Algieiri, you never brought him up. Spence, TKO 5, Manny UD 12.

I did look at who prime Manny fought at WW. ODH, Clottey and Cotto (145). You refuse to be honest about where they were relative to the current crop of WW's.

Crawfrod, Spence and Thurman (when healthy) are top 10 p4p boxers. ODH and Clottey weren't when prime manny fought them. Cotto was, I acknowledged that.

Because they aren't, you want to bring up wins from a different period then the prime period you outlined, 2008-10. You keep posting size all the time knowing those bigger guys are not boxers at the level Spence, Crawford, Thurman or Danny are.

Manny is a 1st ballot HOF'er but he isn't a 1st ballot HOF'er @ WW. You just can't accept that. AT ww he is 10-4.

yeah when did manny fought algieri??? was pac in his "prime"?? what an idiot!!! keyword; "prime"!!!!

the fighters i brought up when pac fought them, he was in his prime. im comparing those fighters with the one that spence fought!!!

but you on the other hand, says i cant do that, yet you assumed manny will have problem with spence because of his size and style. which is what you just told me not to do!!

im bringing up fighters that pac have fought and won! the type of reason why you said spence will beat manny is why i brought those fighters up!! because pac has already fought bigger guys, boxers, etc. and he won!!!! where as for spence, all you are doing here is assuming that his size/style will give pac problems.

[Bronx2245]

and pac beat bradley!! lol!!!! spence or crawford is not on marquez level.. stop fooling yourself.. 2012 is not a "prime" pacquaio.. prime pac walks thru all those guys, its foolish of you to say he wont walk thru danny g, porter??? lmao!!!!!!!!!!!!

Pac was only 34 in 2012, and Marquez was 39! When do you think Pac was no longer in his prime?

[Bronx2245]

28-34? lmao!!! 7 years in his prime? with his fighting style? lmao!!!! when pac fought cotto, pac was 30!! that's when he was in his prime. pac at 34, is when he fought rios, that's after the marquez ko.. so pac was still in his prime to you around that time? you trippin'! lol

34 is still PRIME to me! If Pac was so good when he beat Cotto, he wouldn't have needed a 145 lb. catch-weight! Lol! Floyd beat Oscar and Cotto at 154, no catch-weight, and Floyd is older than Cotto!

[Lion81]

He was a roided cheat, that's why.

[Bronx2245]

and marquez didnt destroyed a prime pac.. marquez was getting whooped on before he knocked pac out!!! you trippin'!!

Didn't Marquez drop Pac in the 2nd too? Oh, that part! Don't forget Marquez was 39 in 2012, when he decapitated 34 year old PRIME Manny!

[flojspot80]

If you don't get the difference between Spence and Clottey then there is no point to keep discussing this. Manny beat stand still bums. Spence is not that. Clottey was never seen as one of the 5-7 best fighters in the world like Spence.

It's me taking into consideration everything. Again, prime WW manny fought 35 yr old ODH, and Clottey at 147 and Cotto at 145 (who didn't have his trainer because he went with Manny).

That isn't a resume that indicates in his prime he's running through Spence, Thurman, Porter and Danny.

COTTO AT 147 canT beat many at 145 he was knock down like 2 or 3 times...I BET MY HOUSE HE CANT BEAT MANNY AT 147 if that's what you are trying to imply.