Break Down of the 2018 HOF Nominees

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • crold1
    Undisputed Champion
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Apr 2005
    • 6354
    • 328
    • 122
    • 19,304

    #1

    Break Down of the 2018 HOF Nominees

    Annual break down of the Modern HOF ballot

    http://www.bwaa.org/single-post/2018/10/12/BWAA-Info-Sheet-For-IBHOF-Nominees
  • Mike D
    Abnormal Human Being
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Jul 2012
    • 13069
    • 1,747
    • 2,352
    • 73,360

    #2
    Great to see Brian Sutherland and Kenny Rainford on the list. I fully expect Brian to be inducted (who doesn't) but I don't think Rainford should get in due to his PED history

    Comment

    • chrisJS
      Undisputed Champion
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Mar 2007
      • 8989
      • 331
      • 64
      • 78,477

      #3
      Rafa!!! Hope he gets in.

      I think Casamayor deserves to be on the ballot. He had a much better career than Kessler and John.

      Comment

      • ShoulderRoll
        Join The Great Resist
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Oct 2009
        • 56349
        • 10,189
        • 5,035
        • 763,445

        #4
        I like Rafael Marquez, Michael Moorer, and Wilfredo Vasquez from that list.

        Yuri Arbachakov might not have a Hall of Fame caliber resume but I love his boxing style.

        Comment

        • Santa_
          Banned
          Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
          • Mar 2015
          • 14673
          • 1,417
          • 378
          • 143,233

          #5
          Great list!


          These one's stick out for me.


          Rafael Marquez

          Career: 1995-2013

          Major Titles: IBF bantamweight (February 15, 2003-March 16, 2007; Vacated); WBC super bantamweight (March 3, 2007-August 4, 2007)

          Hailed from: Mexico City, Mexico

          Record: 41-9-0 (37 KO) BoxRec Record

          Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 8-6 (6 KO)

          Champions/Titlists faced: Victor Rabanales, Mark Johnson, Tim Austin, Mauricio Pastrana, Israel Vasquez, Juan Manuel Lopez, Toshiaki Nishioka, Eric Aiken, Cristian Mijares
          Champions/Titlists defeated: Mark Johnson (SD 10, TKO 8), Tim Austin (TKO 8), Mauricio Pastrana (UD 12, TKO 8), Israel Vasquez (RTD 7, KO 3), Eric Aiken (KO 1)



          Rafael Marquez learned his craft at the feet of legendary trainer Arturo “Cuyo” Hernandez. He turned professional at age twenty, losing a tough pro debut to the veteran Rabanales, and joined older brother Juan Manuel under the guidance of Ignacio Beristain. A technician out for blood, Marquez combined heavy hands with a vulnerable chin and became a crowd favorite in no time. After twenty-eight fights, he stepped up in class to meet ultra-talented Mark “Too Sharp” Johnson in October 2001. He took an unconvincing split decision win but stopped him four months later. In February 2003, he stopped undefeated Tim Austin and became The Ring’s #1 bantamweight for the next four years. Even so, it was and will forever be the four-fight series with Israel Vazquez at Jr. featherweight that places Marquez among history’s great Mexican warriors. When the smoke cleared, they stood as equals. “He had it all,” Marquez said about Vazquez. Twice, however, Marquez had more.



          Ivan Calderon

          Career: 2001-2012
          Major titles: WBO minimumweight (May 3, 2003 – April 28, 2007, vacated), WBO light flyweight (August 25, 2007 – August 28, 2010)
          Hailed from: Guaynabo, Puerto Rico
          Record: 35-3-1 (6 KO)
          Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 11-3-1 (1 KO)

          Champions/Titlists faced: Eduardo Ray Marquez, Alex Sanchez, Edgar Cardenas, Roberto Leyva, Daniel Reyes, Isaac Bustos, Hugo Cazares (twice), Nelson Dieppa, Rodel Mayol (twice), Giovani Segura (twice), Moises Fuentes

          Champions/Titlists defeated: Eduardo Ray Marquez (TW 9), Alex Sanchez (W 12), Edgar Cardenas (KO 11), Roberto Leyva (W 12), Daniel Reyes (W 12), Isaac Bustos (W 12), Hugo Cazares (W 12, TW 7), Nelson Dieppa (W 12), Rodel Mayol (TW 7)



          Calderon overcame his profound lack of power as well as his short height and reach with superior mobility, timely counter-punching, impressive strategic command and defensive skills that some declared the best of his era. The Puerto Rican held a major title almost continuously for more than seven years, an impressive achievement when one considers how quickly fighters in the extreme low weight classes age. He recorded 11 successful defenses of the WBO minimumweight belt as well as six more defenses of the WBO's 108-pound title, some of which were aired in the U.S. on pay-per-view undercards. He defeated nine men who held titles and, from time to time, executed his defensive moves with such flair that crowds shouted "ole" when he made his opponents miss.



          Genaro Hernandez

          Career: 1984-1998

          Major Titles: WBA super featherweight (November 22,1991-November 12, 1994, Vacated), WBC super featherweight (March 22, 1997-October 3, 1998)

          Hailed from: Los Angeles, California

          Record: 38-2-1 (17 KO) Boxrec record

          Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 5-2-1 (3 KO)

          Champions/Titlists faced: Daniel Londas, Raul Perez, Jorge Paez, Oscar de la Hoya, Azumah Nelson, Carlos Hernandez, Floyd Mayweather Jr.

          Champions/Titlists defeated: Daniel Londas (KO 9), Raul Perez (KO 8), Jorge Paez (KO 8), Azumah Nelson (SD 12), Carlos Hernandez (UD 12)



          At 5-foot-11 and owning a 72-inch reach, "Chicanito's" willowy frame was built for long-range boxing but his skill and toughness allowed him to prosper in close. Won the WBA title by stopping hometown hero Daniel Londas in France and of his eight defenses of that belt three were on the road (two in Japan, one in Mexico). Following a non-title TKO of Jorge Paez, Hernandez challenged Oscar de la Hoya for his WBO lightweight title. He held his own but an uppercut shattered his nose in round six and prompted him to surrender at round's end. Three fights later he challenged WBC 130-pound king Azumah Nelson and thoroughly out-boxed him to win a decision. However, the fight was best remembered for Hernandez choosing to continue despite being illegally hit in the throat. Hernandez's career ended against an ambitious 21-year-old Floyd Mayweather Jr., who forced Hernandez to retire between rounds eight and nine.



          Julian Jackson

          Career: 1981-1998

          Major Titles: WBA junior middleweight (November 21, 1987-July 1989, Vacated), WBC middleweight (November 24, 1990-May 8, 1993; March 17, 1995-August 19, 1995)

          Hailed from: U.S. ****** Islands

          Record: 55-6-0 (49 KO) Boxrec Record

          Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 3-5 (3 KO)

          Champions/Titlists faced: Mike McCallum, In Chul Baek, Buster Drayton, Terry Norris, Gerald McClellan, Quincy Taylor, Verno Phillips

          Champions/Titlists defeated: In Chul Baek (KO 3), Buster Drayton (KO 3), Terry Norris (KO 2)



          Pound-for-pound and shot-for-shot, "The Hawk" ranks as one of history's most destructive one-punch knockout artists. He shook the unshakable Mike McCallum in round one before succumbing in round two of his first major title shot. Three fights later he won the first of three vacant crowns by stopping In Chul Baek in three. He stiffened the sturdy Buster Drayton with a hook, Terry Norris with a right, and won his first belt at 160 when, with his eye closing, he cranked an overhand right that left Herol Graham unconscious. His prowess was such that his record once read 43-1 (42 KO), with a streak of 37 consecutive wins inside the distance along the way. Once his prime disappeared, it did so dramatically as he went 9-5 in his last 14 fights, all five losses by KO. During that stretch, he still won a second 160-pound title at age 35 by stretching Agostino Cardamone in two.



          Meldrick Taylor

          Career: 1984-2002

          Major Titles: IBF light welterweight (September 3, 1988-March 17, 1990), WBA welterweight (January 19, 1991-October 31, 1992)

          Hailed from: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

          Record: 38-8-1 (20 KO) Boxrec record

          Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 2-4 (1 KO)

          Champions/Titlists faced: James McGirt, Julio Cesar Chavez, Aaron Davis, Terry Norris, Crisanto Espana

          Champions/Titlists defeated: James McGirt (TKO 12), Aaron Davis (UD 12)



          At 17, Meldrick Taylor was heralded as the most promising gold-medalist to emerge from the legendary 1984 American Olympic boxing team. A super-fast boxer from a North Philadelphia ******, he fought like a brawler despite his talents. Taylor was on the brink of glory when he faced Julio Cesar Chavez in a March 1990 Junior Welterweight unification classic. He outworked the Mexican legend and was ahead on the scorecards when Chavez knocked him down in the twelfth. He rose, was given the mandatory eight-count, but failed to respond to the referee’s questions. The fight was stopped with two seconds left. Taylor recovered with a WBA title win at welterweight over Aaron Davis but was never the same. An ill-advised foray at Jr. Middleweight saw him stopped by Terry Norris and his career became a cause for concern. Nevertheless, his unforgettable performance against Chavez in The Ring’s “Fight of the Decade” points toward greatness.



          Wilfredo Vazquez

          Career: 1981-2002

          Major Titles: WBA bantamweight (October 4, 1987-May 9, 1988); WBA super bantamweight (March 27, 1992-May 13, 1995); WBA featherweight (May 18, 1996-March 24, 1998; relinquished title)

          Hailed from: Bayamon, Puerto Rico

          Record: 56-9-2 (41 KO) Boxrec record

          Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 8-7-1 (5 KO)

          Champions/Titlists faced: Antonio Avelar, Orlando Canizales, Antonio Cermeno, Israel Contreras, Khaokor Galaxy, Naseem Hamed, Thierry Jacob, Miguel Lora, Luis Mendoza, Takuya Muguruma, Chan Yong Park, Juan Polo Perez, Raul Perez, Eloy Rojas,

          Champions/Titlists defeated: Orlando Canizales (SD 12), Thierry Jacob (KO 8, KO 10), Luis Mendoza (UD 12), Chan Yong Park (KO 10), Juan Polo Perez (UD 12), Raul Perez (KO 3), Eloy Rojas (KO 11)



          Vazquez began learning the fundamentals of the sweet science two weeks after his father died. To honor his memory, 18-year-old Vazquez wanted to win a title like his father’s hero Wilfredo Gomez. After 17 amateur fights he turned pro with a four-round decision loss but quickly developed into a two-fisted bomber. He lost his first title shot and then came up short in a shootout to Avelar but rebounded and won his first title at bantamweight with a knockout. His reign was underwhelming. He fought a draw with Muguruma and lost to Galaxy, but soon hit his stride as a 122-pounder. He avenged a previous loss to Perez by bombing him out in three rounds and piled up nine defenses. Presumed to be past his prime when he lost the belt to Cermeno at age 35, Vasquez confounded experts when he stopped lineal and WBA featherweight champ Eloy Rojas in come-from-behind fashion the following year. He notched four defenses of the belt before relinquishing it to fight Naseem Hamed instead of taking a rematch with Cermeno. Vasquez gave a credible effort before Hamed stopped him in seven. He retired at age 42 after winning his last four fights.

          Comment

          • crold1
            Undisputed Champion
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Apr 2005
            • 6354
            • 328
            • 122
            • 19,304

            #6
            Originally posted by chrisJS
            Rafa!!! Hope he gets in.

            I think Casamayor deserves to be on the ballot. He had a much better career than Kessler and John.
            I agree. Don't know that his career was better per se, but I think his best form was a hair better. It's close. He and Kessler have best wins of similar quality (Froch/Corrales) and both tended to come up short against the rest. Casa was arguably better against Castillo, Frietas, and Marquez than Kessler was against Calz/Ward...but he never had a tank night like the Santa Cruz fight.

            John is a head scratcher. He had a debatable win over Marquez and stats against mostly whatever. How that makes the ballot before Corrales, for instance, eludes me. But Ottke is on there too.

            Comment

            • crold1
              Undisputed Champion
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Apr 2005
              • 6354
              • 328
              • 122
              • 19,304

              #7
              Originally posted by Santa_
              Great list!


              These one's stick out for me.


              Rafael Marquez

              Career: 1995-2013

              Major Titles: IBF bantamweight (February 15, 2003-March 16, 2007; Vacated); WBC super bantamweight (March 3, 2007-August 4, 2007)

              Hailed from: Mexico City, Mexico

              Record: 41-9-0 (37 KO) BoxRec Record

              Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 8-6 (6 KO)

              Champions/Titlists faced: Victor Rabanales, Mark Johnson, Tim Austin, Mauricio Pastrana, Israel Vasquez, Juan Manuel Lopez, Toshiaki Nishioka, Eric Aiken, Cristian Mijares
              Champions/Titlists defeated: Mark Johnson (SD 10, TKO 8), Tim Austin (TKO 8), Mauricio Pastrana (UD 12, TKO 8), Israel Vasquez (RTD 7, KO 3), Eric Aiken (KO 1)



              Rafael Marquez learned his craft at the feet of legendary trainer Arturo “Cuyo” Hernandez. He turned professional at age twenty, losing a tough pro debut to the veteran Rabanales, and joined older brother Juan Manuel under the guidance of Ignacio Beristain. A technician out for blood, Marquez combined heavy hands with a vulnerable chin and became a crowd favorite in no time. After twenty-eight fights, he stepped up in class to meet ultra-talented Mark “Too Sharp” Johnson in October 2001. He took an unconvincing split decision win but stopped him four months later. In February 2003, he stopped undefeated Tim Austin and became The Ring’s #1 bantamweight for the next four years. Even so, it was and will forever be the four-fight series with Israel Vazquez at Jr. featherweight that places Marquez among history’s great Mexican warriors. When the smoke cleared, they stood as equals. “He had it all,” Marquez said about Vazquez. Twice, however, Marquez had more.



              Ivan Calderon

              Career: 2001-2012
              Major titles: WBO minimumweight (May 3, 2003 – April 28, 2007, vacated), WBO light flyweight (August 25, 2007 – August 28, 2010)
              Hailed from: Guaynabo, Puerto Rico
              Record: 35-3-1 (6 KO)
              Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 11-3-1 (1 KO)

              Champions/Titlists faced: Eduardo Ray Marquez, Alex Sanchez, Edgar Cardenas, Roberto Leyva, Daniel Reyes, Isaac Bustos, Hugo Cazares (twice), Nelson Dieppa, Rodel Mayol (twice), Giovani Segura (twice), Moises Fuentes

              Champions/Titlists defeated: Eduardo Ray Marquez (TW 9), Alex Sanchez (W 12), Edgar Cardenas (KO 11), Roberto Leyva (W 12), Daniel Reyes (W 12), Isaac Bustos (W 12), Hugo Cazares (W 12, TW 7), Nelson Dieppa (W 12), Rodel Mayol (TW 7)



              Calderon overcame his profound lack of power as well as his short height and reach with superior mobility, timely counter-punching, impressive strategic command and defensive skills that some declared the best of his era. The Puerto Rican held a major title almost continuously for more than seven years, an impressive achievement when one considers how quickly fighters in the extreme low weight classes age. He recorded 11 successful defenses of the WBO minimumweight belt as well as six more defenses of the WBO's 108-pound title, some of which were aired in the U.S. on pay-per-view undercards. He defeated nine men who held titles and, from time to time, executed his defensive moves with such flair that crowds shouted "ole" when he made his opponents miss.



              Genaro Hernandez

              Career: 1984-1998

              Major Titles: WBA super featherweight (November 22,1991-November 12, 1994, Vacated), WBC super featherweight (March 22, 1997-October 3, 1998)

              Hailed from: Los Angeles, California

              Record: 38-2-1 (17 KO) Boxrec record

              Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 5-2-1 (3 KO)

              Champions/Titlists faced: Daniel Londas, Raul Perez, Jorge Paez, Oscar de la Hoya, Azumah Nelson, Carlos Hernandez, Floyd Mayweather Jr.

              Champions/Titlists defeated: Daniel Londas (KO 9), Raul Perez (KO 8), Jorge Paez (KO 8), Azumah Nelson (SD 12), Carlos Hernandez (UD 12)



              At 5-foot-11 and owning a 72-inch reach, "Chicanito's" willowy frame was built for long-range boxing but his skill and toughness allowed him to prosper in close. Won the WBA title by stopping hometown hero Daniel Londas in France and of his eight defenses of that belt three were on the road (two in Japan, one in Mexico). Following a non-title TKO of Jorge Paez, Hernandez challenged Oscar de la Hoya for his WBO lightweight title. He held his own but an uppercut shattered his nose in round six and prompted him to surrender at round's end. Three fights later he challenged WBC 130-pound king Azumah Nelson and thoroughly out-boxed him to win a decision. However, the fight was best remembered for Hernandez choosing to continue despite being illegally hit in the throat. Hernandez's career ended against an ambitious 21-year-old Floyd Mayweather Jr., who forced Hernandez to retire between rounds eight and nine.



              Julian Jackson

              Career: 1981-1998

              Major Titles: WBA junior middleweight (November 21, 1987-July 1989, Vacated), WBC middleweight (November 24, 1990-May 8, 1993; March 17, 1995-August 19, 1995)

              Hailed from: U.S. ****** Islands

              Record: 55-6-0 (49 KO) Boxrec Record

              Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 3-5 (3 KO)

              Champions/Titlists faced: Mike McCallum, In Chul Baek, Buster Drayton, Terry Norris, Gerald McClellan, Quincy Taylor, Verno Phillips

              Champions/Titlists defeated: In Chul Baek (KO 3), Buster Drayton (KO 3), Terry Norris (KO 2)



              Pound-for-pound and shot-for-shot, "The Hawk" ranks as one of history's most destructive one-punch knockout artists. He shook the unshakable Mike McCallum in round one before succumbing in round two of his first major title shot. Three fights later he won the first of three vacant crowns by stopping In Chul Baek in three. He stiffened the sturdy Buster Drayton with a hook, Terry Norris with a right, and won his first belt at 160 when, with his eye closing, he cranked an overhand right that left Herol Graham unconscious. His prowess was such that his record once read 43-1 (42 KO), with a streak of 37 consecutive wins inside the distance along the way. Once his prime disappeared, it did so dramatically as he went 9-5 in his last 14 fights, all five losses by KO. During that stretch, he still won a second 160-pound title at age 35 by stretching Agostino Cardamone in two.



              Meldrick Taylor

              Career: 1984-2002

              Major Titles: IBF light welterweight (September 3, 1988-March 17, 1990), WBA welterweight (January 19, 1991-October 31, 1992)

              Hailed from: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania

              Record: 38-8-1 (20 KO) Boxrec record

              Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 2-4 (1 KO)

              Champions/Titlists faced: James McGirt, Julio Cesar Chavez, Aaron Davis, Terry Norris, Crisanto Espana

              Champions/Titlists defeated: James McGirt (TKO 12), Aaron Davis (UD 12)



              At 17, Meldrick Taylor was heralded as the most promising gold-medalist to emerge from the legendary 1984 American Olympic boxing team. A super-fast boxer from a North Philadelphia ******, he fought like a brawler despite his talents. Taylor was on the brink of glory when he faced Julio Cesar Chavez in a March 1990 Junior Welterweight unification classic. He outworked the Mexican legend and was ahead on the scorecards when Chavez knocked him down in the twelfth. He rose, was given the mandatory eight-count, but failed to respond to the referee’s questions. The fight was stopped with two seconds left. Taylor recovered with a WBA title win at welterweight over Aaron Davis but was never the same. An ill-advised foray at Jr. Middleweight saw him stopped by Terry Norris and his career became a cause for concern. Nevertheless, his unforgettable performance against Chavez in The Ring’s “Fight of the Decade” points toward greatness.



              Wilfredo Vazquez

              Career: 1981-2002

              Major Titles: WBA bantamweight (October 4, 1987-May 9, 1988); WBA super bantamweight (March 27, 1992-May 13, 1995); WBA featherweight (May 18, 1996-March 24, 1998; relinquished title)

              Hailed from: Bayamon, Puerto Rico

              Record: 56-9-2 (41 KO) Boxrec record

              Record against Champions/Titlists and Hall of Famers: 8-7-1 (5 KO)

              Champions/Titlists faced: Antonio Avelar, Orlando Canizales, Antonio Cermeno, Israel Contreras, Khaokor Galaxy, Naseem Hamed, Thierry Jacob, Miguel Lora, Luis Mendoza, Takuya Muguruma, Chan Yong Park, Juan Polo Perez, Raul Perez, Eloy Rojas,

              Champions/Titlists defeated: Orlando Canizales (SD 12), Thierry Jacob (KO 8, KO 10), Luis Mendoza (UD 12), Chan Yong Park (KO 10), Juan Polo Perez (UD 12), Raul Perez (KO 3), Eloy Rojas (KO 11)



              Vazquez began learning the fundamentals of the sweet science two weeks after his father died. To honor his memory, 18-year-old Vazquez wanted to win a title like his father’s hero Wilfredo Gomez. After 17 amateur fights he turned pro with a four-round decision loss but quickly developed into a two-fisted bomber. He lost his first title shot and then came up short in a shootout to Avelar but rebounded and won his first title at bantamweight with a knockout. His reign was underwhelming. He fought a draw with Muguruma and lost to Galaxy, but soon hit his stride as a 122-pounder. He avenged a previous loss to Perez by bombing him out in three rounds and piled up nine defenses. Presumed to be past his prime when he lost the belt to Cermeno at age 35, Vasquez confounded experts when he stopped lineal and WBA featherweight champ Eloy Rojas in come-from-behind fashion the following year. He notched four defenses of the belt before relinquishing it to fight Naseem Hamed instead of taking a rematch with Cermeno. Vasquez gave a credible effort before Hamed stopped him in seven. He retired at age 42 after winning his last four fights.
              Marquez was my first check mark, followed by Santos Laciar. Still mulling over the rest.

              Comment

              • Tony Trick-Pony
                Banned
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • Feb 2014
                • 16950
                • 1,408
                • 3,121
                • 139,355

                #8
                I'd like to see Meldrick and Julian jackson get in. Julian had incredible power. And Meldrick gave us that first Chavez fight which was extraordinary.

                Comment

                • chrisJS
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Mar 2007
                  • 8989
                  • 331
                  • 64
                  • 78,477

                  #9
                  Originally posted by crold1
                  Marquez was my first check mark, followed by Santos Laciar. Still mulling over the rest.
                  Surely Gilberto Roman is long overdue his induction?

                  Re: your response to my Casamayor post - there’s a LOT of names far more worthy than John and others. Rafael Herrera being obvious and Jose Legra too.

                  Comment

                  • iamboxing
                    ******a facking game
                    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                    • Dec 2016
                    • 6421
                    • 672
                    • 760
                    • 29,458

                    #10
                    I can't believe Rafael Marquez isn't in the HOF yet

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP