Your P4P top 10 list?

[UNBIASED BOXING]

1) Crawford
2) Usyk - His demolition of Briedis and win over elite Briedis puts him at #2 on my list.
3) Canelo
4) Lomachenko - I'm really torn about placing Lomachenko here, to be honest.
5) Rungvisai
6) Mikey Garcia
7) Golovkin
8) Errol Spence Jr.
9) Naoya Inoue
10) Santa Cruz

[chrisJS]

There's a lot of these threads the last few days. I also posted a consensus p4p based on ESPN, Ring, TBR (which was always said to be gospel) combined results and they have 1. Loma 2. Crawford 3. Canelo 4. GGG 5. Garcia 6. Usyk 7. Rungvisai 8. Inoue 9. Spence 10. Santa Cruz

MY personal is
1. Lomachenko
2. Crawford
3. Usyk
4. Inoue
5. GGG
6. Canelo
7. Rungvisai
8. Garcia
9. Spence
10. Estrada

I think the bottom 4 could go any order and also Santa Cruz, Joshua, Hurd, Nietes have good claims. I have GGG over Canelo because like many/most I felt he won both fights but he's slipping by the day. I think the top 3 have created some distance but if Inoue wins the WBSS he'll have really impressed me.

[Hatesrats]

1. Terence "Bud" Crawford
2. Vasili "Hi-Tek" Lomachenko
3. Oleksandr "The Cat" Usyk
4. Mikey Garcia
5. Saul "Canelo" Alvarez
6. Srisaket Sor Rungvisai
7. Gennady "GGG" Golovkin
8. Leo Santa Cruz
9. Naoya "Kaibutsu" Inoue
*10. Keith "One Time" Thurman
(About to drop off because of inactivity)

YES I still have Keff as my #1 147lbs above Spence. Don't @me

[Dodger07]

1- Lomachenko
2- Usyk
3- Canelo
4- Crawford
5- GGG
6- Rungvisai
7- Mikey
8- Inoue
9- Spence
10- Joshua

[sunny31]

1) Crawford
2) Usyk - His demolition of Briedis and win over elite Briedis puts him at #2 on my list.
3) Canelo
4) Lomachenko - I'm really torn about placing Lomachenko here, to be honest.
5) Rungvisai
6) Mikey Garcia
7) Golovkin
8) Errol Spence Jr.
9) Naoya Inoue
10) Santa Cruz

Too many of these threads, you could have recycled another one

[UNBIASED BOXING]

There's a lot of these threads the last few days. I also posted a consensus p4p based on ESPN, Ring, TBR (which was always said to be gospel) combined results and they have 1. Loma 2. Crawford 3. Canelo 4. GGG 5. Garcia 6. Usyk 7. Rungvisai 8. Inoue 9. Spence 10. Santa Cruz

MY personal is
1. Lomachenko
2. Crawford
3. Usyk
4. Inoue
5. GGG
6. Canelo
7. Rungvisai
8. Garcia
9. Spence
10. Estrada

I think the bottom 4 could go any order and also Santa Cruz, Joshua, Hurd, Nietes have good claims. I have GGG over Canelo because like many/most I felt he won both fights but he's slipping by the day. I think the top 3 have created some distance but if Inoue wins the WBSS he'll have really impressed me.

I put Canelo high, because I accept the judges decision even if I think Golovkin could have gotten the nod. More importantly, I feel like Canelo deserves credit for the move to middleweight (even if he was fighting at 155). I also acknowledge GGG as slipping due to age. If Inoue wins the WBSS, he'll fly up my list, no doubt, unless the other names keep up with his achievements.

1. Terence "Bud" Crawford
2. Vasili "Hi-Tek" Lomachenko
3. Oleksandr "The Cat" Usyk
4. Mikey Garcia
5. Saul "Canelo" Alvarez
6. Srisaket Sor Rungvisai
7. Gennady "GGG" Golovkin
8. Leo Santa Cruz
9. Naoya "Kaibutsu" Inoue
*10. Keith "One Time" Thurman
(About to drop off because of inactivity)

YES I still have Keff as my #1 147lbs above Spence. Don't @me

I think everyone would have Thurman on their P4P and their #1 rated welterweight if he was active. It's been almost 2 years, though. Can't argue to keep him on anymore.

[Mexican_Puppet]

1-Canelo
2-Loma.
3-Crawford.
4-Mikey.
5-Sor.
6-GGG.
7-Usyk.
8-Inoue.
9-Santa Cruz.
10-Thurman

[KTFOKING]

1) Crawford
2) Usyk - His demolition of Briedis and win over elite Briedis puts him at #2 on my list.
3) Canelo
4) Lomachenko - I'm really torn about placing Lomachenko here, to be honest.
5) Rungvisai
6) Mikey Garcia
7) Golovkin
8) Errol Spence Jr.
9) Naoya Inoue
10) Santa Cruz

Very nice list. Had the same 10 as me.

1. Lomachenko
2. Crawford
3. Usyk
4. Canelo
5. Garcia
6. Inoue
7. Golovkin
8. Spence
9. SSR
10. LSC

I've been having GGG/Spence above Inoue, but that's one change I made. Inoue after the WBSS tournament has a chance to crack the top 5. Spence if he gets the elite WWs soon will as well.

SSR is interesting. Two wins over Chocolatito and the Estrada win are very impressive. Definitely can be placed higher.

LSC with two wins over Mares and Frampton gets the nod over Charlo/Hurd for me.

Pacquiao still has a case as well if you believe he beat Horn.

Then guys like Stevenson/Jack/etc are on the brink.

[H.B.Viper]

(1)Loma
(2)Mikey Garcia
(3)Canelo
(4)Usyk
(5)Santa Cruz
(6)SSR
(7)Miguel Berchelt
(8)Jared Hurd
(9)Jermell Charlo
(10)Thurman
Again MHO.
I go with guys who fight , meet mandatory defenses, & REALLY. clean out divisions.
Again. I don't do fantasy, or potentially based fighter who pass the media eye test(Crawford, & a couple others).
Just guys who thump.

[chrisJS]

(1)Loma
(2)Mikey Garcia
(3)Canelo
(4)Usyk
(5)Santa Cruz
(6)SSR
(7)Miguel Berchelt
(8)Jared Hurd
(9)Jermell Charlo
(10)Thurman
Again MHO.
I go with guys who fight , meet mandatory defenses, & REALLY. clean out divisions.
Again. I don't do fantasy, or potentially based fighter who pass the media eye test(Crawford, & a couple others).
Just guys who thump.

On what planet has Charlo for example "thumped" more than Crawford? Thumped his chest?

Crawford cleaned out 135 beating the #1, 2 & 3 (including the unbeaten Gamboa who was on the cusp of p4p and looked potentially special) and then won every title at 140 against a variety of styles. Crawford has cleaned out more divisions then anyone on your list FYI.

I get that he hasn't got a glittering list of opponents but is resume is better than most of your list, his accomplishments far better and obviously his skill which is a bit more subjective but still clearly obvious to me and most.