Is Mayweather's 2007-2015 run of consecutive opponents the best ever?!?!?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Joe Beamish
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Aug 2014
    • 3475
    • 157
    • 42
    • 30,582

    #31
    The list doesn't have much that isn't "coming up from a smaller weight" AND "past prime" in it.

    Great names, though. Good resume, but not on par with (say) Leonard's defeats of Benitez, Duran, Hearns, all of whom were genuinely dangerous in the ring.

    I'd rate Cotto as Floyd's best win in that stretch. But please. DLH was way past prime and practically inactive. Marquez and Pacquaio are midgets -- and past prime. Hatton is a good win, but again -- a little dude.

    Guerrero is OK. But he was P4P because he came up from a smaller weight.

    Again, nothing dangerous in that run except maybe Cotto. The others are puny and old.

    Comment

    • sbbigmike
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Dec 2012
      • 1990
      • 157
      • 38
      • 24,971

      #32
      Originally posted by TheBigLug
      Give me anyone's resume and i'll tear it apart like this. It's very easy when you have an agenda.

      Let's be fair, most of Trinidad's opponents in his WW run were very average. Arguably lost to De La Hoya, who threw the fight away and the best names during the run were against guys that were previously smaller lightweights or Super featherweights, like Camacho.

      Look at some (most) of the names Trinidad had in that run. Floyd would be crucified by boxing fans if he fought some of them.

      See, easy isn't it? - I actually really rate Trinidad. I'm simply showing how easy it is to tear a resume apart.
      Tito should be crucified for the names he avoided in or around weight classes and times he reigned in them....

      Do I need to break down Tito resume really, boy would have 10 losses from 147-160 had he fought in this day, he was getting into fire fights with mamadou, his skillset doesn't stand my time eye test

      Comment

      • mcdonalds
        Undisputed Champion
        • Oct 2017
        • 3700
        • 298
        • 11
        • 106,172

        #33
        Originally posted by Tony Trick-Pony
        Oscar's '95- '99 run was similar-
        John-John Molina
        Genaro Hernandez (Younger, fesher version)
        Miguel Angel Gonzalez
        These guys were champions at lighter weight classes. So yea they are good wins but you criticized robert guerrero for not being proven at 147, so who did these guys beat as lightweights or super lightweight? At least guerrero had fought at 147 before.

        Jesse James Leija
        Darryl Tyson
        David Kamau
        Hector Camacho
        Wilfredo Rivera
        Patrick Charpentier
        They weren't champions or ranked P4P when oscar fought them.

        Comment

        • sbbigmike
          Undisputed Champion
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Dec 2012
          • 1990
          • 157
          • 38
          • 24,971

          #34
          Originally posted by Tony Trick-Pony
          Oscar's '95- '99 run was similar-

          John-John Molina
          Rafael Ruelas
          Genaro Hernandez (Younger, fesher version)
          Jesse James Leija
          Darryl Tyson
          Julio Cesar Chavez, Sr.
          Miguel Angel Gonzalez
          Pernell Whitaker
          David Kamau
          Hector Camacho
          Wilfredo Rivera
          Patrick Charpentier
          Julio Cesar Chavez, Sr. rematch
          Ike Quartey

          He also won ten of these by stoppage.

          It's a good run by Floyd but I don't see that it's that exceptional.

          I mean, Judah? Who didn't beat Judah when he stepped up?

          Guerrero had no significant wins at 147.

          It's good but not the best run ever. If so, then the sport hasn't produced much.
          The ghost stopped Manny in sparring, Floyd ducking the ghost and that southpaw style...

          Comment

          • Tony Trick-Pony
            Banned
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Feb 2014
            • 16950
            • 1,408
            • 3,121
            • 139,355

            #35
            Originally posted by mcdonalds
            These guys were champions at lighter weight classes. So yea they are good wins but you criticized robert guerrero for not being proven at 147, so who did these guys beat as lightweights or super lightweight? At least guerrero had fought at 147 before.



            They weren't champions or ranked P4P when oscar fought them.
            Good God. That sig is Satanic or something. Sick shlt...

            Comment

            • dmocchi
              Up and Comer
              • Dec 2008
              • 42
              • 4
              • 0
              • 7,907

              #36
              Floyd’s best and most dangerous fight was against Diego Corrales. Thereafter he was always deemed favorite coming in, not because of his level of talent but the state of his opposition.( even in the 2nd Castillo fight).
              Floyd will always be remembered as a talented but unchallenged champion...

              Comment

              • Vlad_
                Banned
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • May 2017
                • 13966
                • 3,241
                • 1,478
                • 836,213

                #37
                Floyd had a very good run indeed.

                Comment

                • jas
                  Voice of Reason
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • Jul 2005
                  • 22525
                  • 936
                  • 912
                  • 1,059,614

                  #38
                  Originally posted by mcdonalds
                  oops i meant to say 2006-2015

                  Just based off of consecutive opponents.

                  Zab Judah: 147 IBF welterweight champion. Coming off a loss to baldomir so it's not that impressive, but we are only getting started

                  Baldomir: 147 WBC and Lineal champion. #2 Welterweight

                  Oscar de la hoya: 154 WBC champion. Hall of famer

                  Ricky Hatton: #8 P4P. WBA Welterweight champion. IBF and the ring light welterweight champion.

                  Marquez: #2 P4P (Lightweight doe). hall of famer

                  Mosley: #3 P4P and 147 WBA champion. Hall of famer

                  Ortiz: 147 WBC champion # 2 welterweight boxer

                  Cotto: 154 WBA light middleweight champion. #2 Super welterweight boxer. Hall of famer

                  Guerrero: #9 P4P and #3 Welterweight boxer. WBC interim champion

                  Canelo: #9 P4P. 154 WBC and the Ring champion. #1 super welterweight boxer.

                  Maidana (Twice): 147 WBA champion. Just came off a huge win over #9 P4P little bro

                  Pacquiao: #2 P4P, 147 WBO champion, #2 welterweight boxer. Hall of famer

                  Berto: lol

                  ALL HAIL MR TBE

                  Image result for bowing down gif
                  Me playing devils advocate:

                  - judah - coming off a loss to baldomir
                  - baldomir - extremely slow
                  - delahoya- way past prime
                  - mosley - way past prime
                  - cotto - quit before
                  - ortiz - quit before
                  - jmm - 2 weights higher
                  - nelo- green
                  - pac - 1 arm

                  Comment

                  • Real King Kong
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • May 2010
                    • 12029
                    • 460
                    • 24
                    • 105,905

                    #39
                    Baldomir lol. What garbage p4p list had guererro #9?...I keep seeing this.

                    Comment

                    • mcdonalds
                      Undisputed Champion
                      • Oct 2017
                      • 3700
                      • 298
                      • 11
                      • 106,172

                      #40
                      Originally posted by Real King Kong
                      Baldomir lol. What garbage p4p list had guererro #9?...I keep seeing this.
                      He was #9 by the ring magazine and #12 for ESPN.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP