Rate these Middleweight resumes from Best to Worst?

[W1LL]

Rate the following fighters from Best to Worst, based off their top 5 wins:

Jermain Taylor
Bernard Hopkins I
Bernard Hopkins II
Cory Spinks
William Joppy
Sam Soliman

Kelly Pavlik
Jermain Taylor I
Jermain Taylor II
Edison Miranda
Marco Antonio Rubio
Gary Lockett

Sergio Martinez
Kelly Pavlik
Paul Williams
Serhiy Dzinziruk
Darren Barker
Julio Cesar Chavez Jr.

Miguel Cotto
Sergio Martinez
Daniel Geale
N/A
N/A
N/A

Saul Alvarez
Miguel Cotto
Amir Khan
N/A
N/A
N/A

Gennady Golovkin
Daniel Jacobs
David Lemieux
Kell Brook
Martin Murray
Daniel Geale

[W1LL]

Personally, I'd say:

1.) Jermain Taylor
2.) Sergio Martinez
3.) Gennady Golovkin
4.) Kelly Pavlik
5.) Miguel Cotto
6.) Saul Alvarez

[allanperlee]

Canelo and Cotto's resumes are the worst of any lineal middleweight champion ever. It us hard to pico between Pavlik and Taylor since Taylor beat Hopkins and then Pavlik destroyed Taylor. Sérgio Martinez looked sensational in every outung on HBO. He was also an excellent 154 pounder.

[W1LL]

Canelo and Cotto's resumes are the worst of any lineal middleweight champion ever. It us hard to pico between Pavlik and Taylor since Taylor beat Hopkins and then Pavlik destroyed Taylor. Sérgio Martinez looked sensational in every outung on HBO. He was also an excellent 154 pounder.

Yea I would say Sergio had by far the most impressive performances. If we're going solely off names, I'd say Taylor's two wins over B-Hop hold the most value.

[boliodogs]

Rate the following fighters from Best to Worst, based off their top 5 wins:

Jermain Taylor
Bernard Hopkins I
Bernard Hopkins II
Cory Spinks
William Joppy
Sam Soliman

Kelly Pavlik
Jermain Taylor I
Jermain Taylor II
Edison Miranda
Marco Antonio Rubio
Gary Lockett

Sergio Martinez
Kelly Pavlik
Paul Williams
Serhiy Dzinziruk
Darren Barker
Julio Cesar Chavez Jr.

Miguel Cotto
Sergio Martinez
Daniel Geale
N/A
N/A
N/A

Saul Alvarez
Miguel Cotto
Amir Khan
N/A
N/A
N/A

Gennady Golovkin
Daniel Jacobs
David Lemieux
Kell Brook
Martin Murray
Daniel Geale

GGG BEST Martinez 2nd Pavlic 3rd Taylor 4th Canelo 5th Cotto 6th. Cotto and Canelo were terrible pretend middleweight champs who never once defended the middleweight title at the full 160 pounds. If not for crooked judging GGG would have a win over Canelo as well.

[Eddy Current]

Rate the following fighters from Best to Worst, based off their top 5 wins:

Jermain Taylor
Bernard Hopkins I
Bernard Hopkins II
Cory Spinks
William Joppy
Sam Soliman

Kelly Pavlik
Jermain Taylor I
Jermain Taylor II
Edison Miranda
Marco Antonio Rubio
Gary Lockett

Sergio Martinez
Kelly Pavlik
Paul Williams
Serhiy Dzinziruk
Darren Barker
Julio Cesar Chavez Jr.

Miguel Cotto
Sergio Martinez
Daniel Geale
N/A
N/A
N/A

Saul Alvarez
Miguel Cotto
Amir Khan
N/A
N/A
N/A

Gennady Golovkin
Daniel Jacobs
David Lemieux
Kell Brook
Martin Murray
Daniel Geale

The order listed except the last three may just need shuffled around a bit.

[W1LL]

GGG BEST Martinez 2nd Pavlic 3rd Taylor 4th Canelo 5th Cotto 6th. Cotto and Canelo were terrible pretend middleweight champs who never once defended the middleweight title at the full 160 pounds. If not for crooked judging GGG would have a win over Canelo as well.

You think GGG has better wins than B-Hop x2?

[allanperlee]

Yea I would say Sergio had by far the most impressive performances. If we're going solely off names, I'd say Taylor's two wins over B-Hop hold the most value.

Yeah definitely, and thats why i dont know which resume is better lol

[S7V7N]

Yea I would say Sergio had by far the most impressive performances. If we're going solely off names, I'd say Taylor's two wins over B-Hop hold the most value.

Pavlik since he has Taylor x2.

Taylor with the 2 B-hop wins but that's it. Soliman was 40 & hobbled.

GGG without counting Alvarez a win really hurts him here.

Sergio is the only one on the list with 2 names that weren't really MW's, Williams & Dzinziruk. Are we really rating Chavez & Barker highly?

Saul

Miguel.

[lparm]

Rate the following fighters from Best to Worst, based off their top 5 wins:

Jermain Taylor
Bernard Hopkins I
Bernard Hopkins II
Cory Spinks
William Joppy
Sam Soliman

Kelly Pavlik
Jermain Taylor I
Jermain Taylor II
Edison Miranda
Marco Antonio Rubio
Gary Lockett

Sergio Martinez
Kelly Pavlik
Paul Williams
Serhiy Dzinziruk
Darren Barker
Julio Cesar Chavez Jr.

Miguel Cotto
Sergio Martinez
Daniel Geale
N/A
N/A
N/A

Saul Alvarez
Miguel Cotto
Amir Khan
N/A
N/A
N/A

Gennady Golovkin
Daniel Jacobs
David Lemieux
Kell Brook
Martin Murray
Daniel Geale

Easy.

Canelo
Cotto
Pavlik
Taylor
Sergio
GGG