Should Canelo and Thurman stay rank in p4p rankings?

[_Rexy_]

Did anyone even have Thurman in their top 10 p4p a year ago?

[GhostofDempsey]

P4P rankings are all over the place. Ring still has Kovalev and Rigo in their top ten. ESPN has Kovalev, Wilder and Thurman on their top ten list.

Boxrec has the most ridiculous list of all of them:

1 Saul Alvarez

2 Terence Crawford

3 Vasyl Lomachenko

4 Gennady Golovkin

5 Wisaksil Wangek

6 Luis Nery

7 Anthony Joshua

8 Miguel Berchelt

9 Jeff Horn

10 Leo Santa Cruz

[_Rexy_]

P4P rankings are all over the place. Ring still has Kovalev and Rigo in their top ten. ESPN has Kovalev, Wilder and Thurman on their top ten list.

Boxrec has the most ridiculous list of all of them:

1 Saul Alvarez

2 Terence Crawford

3 Vasyl Lomachenko

4 Gennady Golovkin

5 Wisaksil Wangek

6 Luis Nery

7 Anthony Joshua

8 Miguel Berchelt

9 Jeff Horn

10 Leo Santa Cruz

yeah, I remember looking at Boxrec's a while ago and thinking "well, that's why I never used their rankings..."

[_Rexy_]

AJ and Horn are top 10 P4P but Inoue isn't?

[boliodogs]

I had Canelo very high so I will keep him in the top 10 until he fights again in September and see how well he fights then. Thurman was not quite in my top 10 even before he was injured. His wins over Garcia and Porter were very close wins and neither Porter or Garcia were even close to being in my top 10.I don't know if Canelo was cheating in past fights because he always tested clean. I am not going to mark him down on past fights because he just recently failed a test for the first time ever. The law doesn't work like that and I don't think like that. People can say if a boxer ever fails any drug test he was cheating his whole career all the want but I don't agree with that. I want proof. It's innocent until proven guilty for me and not guilty from day one based on one failed test.