How would you rate Canelo if he beats GGG?

[Jewish-Reptile]

Both are overrated a draw is about right for both their limited asses.

[BillyBoxing]

If Canelo beats GGG and retires. How would you sum up his career? A lock for the Hall of fame? Is he an all time great??

P4P number 1, first ballot HOFer

[Madison Boxing]

Very high but based on the 1st fight i can't see that happening legitimately. Legitimately is the key word.

[Dodger07]

If no robbery, then he definitely could be considered p4p #1. No other fighter would have an overall resume that comes close to his. Hed probably be a hall of famer with a win as well.

[VatoMulatto]

Low. GGG is a mark ass buster Euro bum.

[The D3vil]

He'd make my top 10.

Y'all know I think GGG is in decline and has been the past 2 years, so I think Canelo should win this fight, but still GGG is a top 10 fighter in the world.

It'd probably put him in the Hall of Fame.

I wouldn't rate him no.1 because I believe he's gotten 3 gifts in his career.

I can overlook 1 gift decision, but Canelo consistently gets gifts.

[Gigantes]

If Canelo beats GGG and retires. How would you sum up his career? A lock for the Hall of fame? Is he an all time great??

Canelo stepped up to the plate when GGG looked regular against Jacob's. A defeat of THIS GGG now doesn't do much

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

He’s probably a lock for the HOF already tbh. If he wins clearly (which I doubt) he hast to be considered a top candidate for p4p king.

[chrisJS]

Canelo stepped up to the plate when GGG looked regular against Jacob's. A defeat of THIS GGG now doesn't do much

Jacobs is a very good fighter and I'd pick him to beat Canelo. He's a style nightmare for Canelo. I do think GGG perhaps peaked already a little bit naturally as he's 36 but if Canelo can win fair and square it solidifies him as a clear first ballot hall of famer and shoots him up inside probably the top 15 Mexican fighters of all-time. He'd need to follow it up with some wins like Andrade, Charlo, Jacobs or a good reign at 168 to enter the top 10 and be considered at ATG though.

Legit win only though. If it's a replica of fight I or he gets some Andre Ward win I'd imagine he'll still be a ways to go to be considered great.

[Gigantes]

Jacobs is a very good fighter and I'd pick him to beat Canelo. He's a style nightmare for Canelo. I do think GGG perhaps peaked already a little bit naturally as he's 36 but if Canelo can win fair and square it solidifies him as a clear first ballot hall of famer and shoots him up inside probably the top 15 Mexican fighters of all-time. He'd need to follow it up with some wins like Andrade, Charlo, Jacobs or a good reign at 168 to enter the top 10 and be considered at ATG though.

Legit win only though. If it's a replica of fight I or he gets some Andre Ward win I'd imagine he'll still be a ways to go to be considered great.

Nice post, I can see where you're coming from. I hope that if he does happen to pull it off, it is like you said, LEGIT.