How would prime Antonio Margarito do today?

[Blu]

How do you guys see prime (2008) Antonio Margarito doing against todays top welterweights?

Does he beat:

Shawn Porter
Kieth Thurman
Danny Garcia
Errol Spence
Terrance Crawford
Jeff Horn
Jessie Vargas
Lucas Matthysse

[Fists_of_Fury]

With or without plaster?

[Blu]

With or without plaster?

Let's just give him the benefit of the doubt and say he was innocent prior to the Mosley fight.

[.!WAR MIKEY!.]

Let's just give him the benefit of the doubt and say he was innocent prior to the Mosley fight.

he defeats them all.

[Thraxox]

Margo out muscles Spence probably, he's bigger than Spence. Gets out boxed by Thurman, stops DSG, stops Porter.

[Dr.Cool]

Let's just give him the benefit of the doubt and say he was innocent prior to the Mosley fight.

Watching the Cotto fight, and then Marg's handwraps being pink, like the plaster ones against Mosley instead of the normal white, is pretty damning.

Take away Cotto and what do you have? A close loss to Paul Williams? Wins over Clottey and Cintron? Good, okay, but a loss in 04 to Dos Santos, a loss in 07 to Paul Williams, and his 09 spanking by Mosley. Without Cotto, Marg is nothing more than a gatekeeper, similar to Vargas today.

[Dr.Cool]

Yea, I gotta say, most of those guys are better than an 09 Mosley. And we saw what Mosley did. I know people always hype up past athletes more, but looking at his resume, it is incredibly weak. A win over Cotto and a close loss to Williams. And the win against Cotto is very suspect. I'm sorry, but saying he beats anyone because of wins over Cintron and Clottey is foolish.

[RomanReigns]

Spence ko hims back to mexico. Thurman, Porter and Garcia out boxes this plodder. He is a useless fighter without the plaster. That is why team arum let him fight Pacquiao.

[Ray*]

A prime Margarito would definitely be a pain at 147 now, he would have a good size advantage and I think he might out hustle all the top contenders now. But I could see Spence holding his own and I can see Thurman dancing around him.

[RomanReigns]

A prime Margarito would definitely be a pain at 147 now, he would have a good size advantage and I think he might out hustle all the top contenders now. But I could see Spence holding his own and I can see Thurman dancing around him.

Plasterito is a terrible boxer.