Can someone explain to aboutfkntime

[D4thincarnation]

no, there are no guidelines.....

other then..... it is common-sense, and it is obvious

put it this way.....

did you REALLY think that Kell Brook was a genuine middleweight just because..... he said so?

..... nobody I know thought that Brook suddenly became a genuine middleweight

Have you ever heard of the "No True Scotsman Fallacy"

I think you really need to read up on it.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Over 700 posts.

Safe to say this is now a legendary thread.

[aboutfkntime]

Have you ever heard of the "No True Scotsman Fallacy"

I think you really need to read up on it.

does the word " genuine " still upset you ?

ok, so..... Canelo was obviously not a genuine middleweight

would you prefer that I used the word " pretend "

as-in..... Canelo was a pretend middloeweight

or would you prefer the word..... " artificial "

the word fake also works nicely

what word did you have in mind ?

[Real King Kong]

78 pages of fanboy ******ity

Agreed....mainly your Canelo fan boy ******ity. Can't bring yourself to even state the weight limits of the jmw and mw divisions.

...and before you go on another tirade...this has nothing to do with Canelo or ggg as far as I'm concerned. It's about the clearly defined limit of the jmw division, and what division someone who exceeds that limit belongs to by simple definition...something you seem to be in denial about.

[aboutfkntime]

Over 700 posts.

Safe to say this is now a legendary thread.

thanks bro

I'd like to say it comes down to hard work and dedication

but perhaps, supreme confidence in my knowledge of the sport..... an unhealthy hatred for casual-fans..... and free internet..... would be more appropriate

[aboutfkntime]

Agreed....mainly your Canelo fan boy ******ity. Can't bring yourself to even state the weight limits of the jmw and mw divisions.

...and before you go on another tirade...this has nothing to do with Canelo or ggg as far as I'm concerned. It's about the clearly defined limit of the jmw division, and what division someone who exceeds that limit belongs to by simple definition...something you seem to be in denial about.

you, my doorknob-level friend..... are attempting to classify a fighter by the "technical" classification of the bout.....

which is horribly flawed, terribly naive..... and moronically ******, considering the fact that this has all been clearly explained

if you think that a guy who weighs 154.1 should be classified as a genuine middleweight..... then you are a ***wit, plain and simple

a calculator-wielding, mathsbook-reading, pansy..... type of ***wit

the bout itself, can technically be described as a middleweight contest..... but any knowledgeable observer knows that it was 2 JMW's fighting 1 pound over the limit..... which is NOT the same thing

put away your calculator foolio

[aboutfkntime]

155lb Canelo was not a genuine middleweight

141lb Garcia, and 141lb Peterson, were not genuine welters when they fought at 141 so that their JWW titles were not at stake

fat-boy Bellew is not a genuine heavyweight

159lb Kell Brook was not a genuine middleweight

need I go on ?

fk you clowns are dumb beyond belief lol

oh, did I remember to say that 155lb Canelo was not a genuine middleweight?

right ^^

[aboutfkntime]

STILL, waiting for an answer to this - and other - questions


tell me why GGG said this about 159lb Brook.....
" he is not a middleweight, He just isn't " ~ Golovkin


I cannot even force you guys to get a clue, can I ?

[Real King Kong]

you, my doorknob-level friend..... are attempting to classify a fighter by the "technical" classification of the bout.....

which is horribly flawed, terribly naive..... and moronically ******, considering the fact that this has all been clearly explained

if you think that a guy who weighs 154.1 should be classified as a genuine middleweight..... then you are a ***wit, plain and simple

a calculator-wielding, mathsbook-reading, pansy..... type of ***wit

the bout itself, can technically be described as a middleweight contest..... but any knowledgeable observer knows that it was 2 JMW's fighting 1 pound over the limit..... which is NOT the same thing

put away your calculator foolio

I don't need to classify anyone as a technical or genuine anything...the weight classes and their weigh in weights define what they are. I don't understand why you're having such a difficult time coming to terms with the fact that Canelo was fighting as a mw when he was over the jmw limit.

If he was a jmw, he'd still be fighting there...Canelo is a mw...deal with it.

[aboutfkntime]

I don't need to classify anyone as a technical or genuine anything...the weight classes and their weigh in weights define what they are. I don't understand why you're having such a difficult time coming to terms with the fact that Canelo was fighting as a mw when he was over the jmw limit.

If he was a jmw, he'd still be fighting there...Canelo is a mw...deal with it.

FACT: only a total ***wit would classify a fighter who weighed 154.1..... as a genuine middleweight

let's leave it there ****-for-brains..... we can agree to disagree

but I would like you to at least attempt the muppet challenge before you leave.....

tell me why YOU think that Golovkin said this about 159lb Kell Brook immediately following their fight.....
" he is not a middleweight, He just isn't " ~ Golovkin

couldn't you at least try to have a clue and display a working knowledge of this sport?..... or is the maths-based, calculator, video-game version..... more your thing?