Comments Thread For: BoxingScene 2017 Prospect of the Year Josh Taylor

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Josh deserves to be prospect of the year 2017 as he was a prospect at the start of the year but turned himself into a contender by the end of the year.

You致e just said it yourself he痴 a contender. Branding him a prospect is ignorant to what he痴 accomplished this year.

[jmrf4435]

This guy is niiiiice

Has some major skills

[DJ Enerate]

You致e just said it yourself he痴 a contender. Branding him a prospect is ignorant to what he痴 accomplished this year.

Its not though. Voting Taylor prospect of 2017 isn't branding him a prospect. It's just stating he was the best prospect of that year as he was the prospect who elevated to a higher level most impressively.

He was voted the prospect of 2017 because he went from prospect to contender by the end of the year. He deserves it for actually achieving that. If he was considered a contender from the start of the year I could see your point. The fact is he was considered a prospect through most of 2017. He was actually on a lot of lists of best prospects put up through the year. Even after the Davies fight he was still seen as a prospect because lots don't rate Davies. The Vasquez win is the one that put him up to contender level as it made people take notice. That win over Vasquez actually made him the best prospect out of all the prospects of 2017 because none of the rest of them had a win that good.

Would you rather the best prospect of 2017 was a fighter who feasted on bums all year rather as the one that achieved a win that put him up to contender level ? Doesn't make sense.

Ya get me ?

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Its not though. Voting Taylor prospect of 2017 isn't branding him a prospect. It's just stating he was the best prospect of that year as he was the prospect who elevated to a higher level most impressively.

He was voted the prospect of 2017 because he went from prospect to contender by the end of the year. He deserves it for actually achieving that. If he was considered a contender from the start of the year I could see your point. The fact is he was considered a prospect through most of 2017. He was actually on a lot of lists of best prospects put up through the year. Even after the Davies fight he was still seen as a prospect because lots don't rate Davies. The Vasquez win is the one that put him up to contender level as it made people take notice. That win over Vasquez actually made him the best prospect out of all the prospects of 2017 because none of the rest of them had a win that good.

Would you rather the best prospect of 2017 was a fighter who feasted on bums all year rather as the one that achieved a win that put him up to contender level ? Doesn't make sense.

Ya get me ?

I get what your saying bro, but that痴 not how I would define the prospect of the year. For me it should be a guy who is actually a prospect, who you expect to go on to become a contender, champion etc not a guy is already proven to be well above prospect level.
It壇 be like awarding Floyd prospect of the year in 98, he was a prospect for the majority of that year but proved by the end of it he was way above that prospect status

[petero]

You obviously never watched this guy.
MV 44 fights never been stopped, that would be a good one for you to watch before the silly comments

[petero]

I still don't remember who he was fighting, but he hit a guy with a flush liver shot and the guy didn't even flinch. If you can't hurt someone from a clean liver flush, then there's something wrong with you.

You obviously never watched Josh Taylor, i believe you are confused

[DJ Enerate]

I get what your saying bro, but that’s not how I would define the prospect of the year. For me it should be a guy who is actually a prospect, who you expect to go on to become a contender, champion etc not a guy is already proven to be well above prospect level.
It’d be like awarding Floyd prospect of the year in 98, he was a prospect for the majority of that year but proved by the end of it he was way above that prospect status

So Taylor was in most lists of prospects through 2017 but you would pick someone else to win prospect of 2017 because Taylor achieved enough to elevate him to contender level by the end ? I believe that makes him win the prospect of the year and I think most would agree with my logic.

Just because he's won prospect of the year it doesn't mean he's still being labelled a prospect. It's nearly 2018, Taylor was the best prospect of 2017 by hitting contender level by the end of they year. Now he's going into 2018 a contender for world honours.

I'm hoping to see TTT win a world title by the end of 2018. I think he'll do it.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

So Taylor was in most lists of prospects through 2017 but you would pick someone else to win prospect of 2017 because Taylor achieved enough to elevate him to contender level by the end ? I believe that makes him win the prospect of the year and I think most would agree with my logic.

Just because he's won prospect of the year it doesn't mean he's still being labelled a prospect. It's nearly 2018, Taylor was the best prospect of 2017 by hitting contender level by the end of they year. Now he's going into 2018 a contender for world honours.

I'm hoping to see TTT win a world title by the end of 2018. I think he'll do it.

I think we just clearly have a very different criteria for how we judge prospect of the year. I always pick the guy who I feel is the strongest prospect at the end of the year not someone who was a strong prospect earlier on in the year.

I think as long as he gets a shot he値l win a world title this year, I知 just unsure whether Cyclone have the money or influence to make it happen, I really rate Taylor, if he fights for a title I値l certainly travel up to Scotland again to watch him

[DJ Enerate]

I think we just clearly have a very different criteria for how we judge prospect of the year. I always pick the guy who I feel is the strongest prospect at the end of the year not someone who was a strong prospect earlier on in the year.

I think as long as he gets a shot he値l win a world title this year, I知 just unsure whether Cyclone have the money or influence to make it happen, I really rate Taylor, if he fights for a title I値l certainly travel up to Scotland again to watch him

If thats your opinion then fair enough man.

I agree. Hopefully he gets the title shot. By the end of 2018 he might be talked about as a future P4P fighter.

[Santa_]

Taylor's a great prospect and is certified contender after after the Vasquez beat down.