How Big Will A W Be For Each Man

[koolkc107]

Crap poll since you can't vote for more than one option and for this poll, I'm going to need to vote for two options at least.

1) It would be the best win for both Rigo and Loma and it'd prove both are worthy contenders for P4P 1.

2) Lomachenko should win as he is bigger and younger, with both of them being fairly even in skill.

I wasn't aware you could make a poll here with more than one voting option.

But, don't think I'd have went that way in any case.

Pick the one that is closest to what you feel strongest.

[Lopez_Boxing]

The biggest win of either man's career.

Rigo is at a disadvantage in that he's significantly smaller, older, and has had no decent competition in a long time. So, naturally, Rigo gets supreme credit if he wins.

That doesn't take anything away from the fact that it would still be Loma's biggest win and that he'd possibly deserve P4P #1 status.

Put the best way possible.

[koolkc107]

I just can't see Loma getting P4P #1 for beating an older fighter, as good as Rigo may be.

And, I can't see Rigo getting it either for beating a guy that passes the eye test with flying colors but is hella short on resume.

Either moves up with a W, but #1 will still be Crawford and I personally have quite a few ranked higher than either and they will not leapfrog all of them.

[koolkc107]

Bumping for votes

[DuckAdonis]

Winner is #1 because he would be the only fighter to have beat a fellow p4p fighter in the current match up. Especially if its rigo since he is moving up 2 divisions facing Loma

[koolkc107]

Winner is #1 because he would be the only fighter to have beat a fellow p4p fighter in the current match up. Especially if its rigo since he is moving up 2 divisions facing Loma

Wasn't Ward vs Kova a tilt between two top P4P guys?

And both of them have way better resumes than either Rigo or Loma.

I can't see the winner here as P4P #1 when there are several guys more tested against top caliber competition.

[DuckAdonis]

Wasn't Ward vs Kova a tilt between two top P4P guys?

And both of them have way better resumes than either Rigo or Loma.

I can't see the winner here as P4P #1 when there are several guys more tested against top caliber competition.

Yeah but the winner Retired so the p4p #1 slot is open

[Boxnation fan]

To me a winner takes number 2 if not 1. I know guys are going to be on my back about it. But these 2 are just that good.

If RIGO WINS, he becomes the CLEAR NUMBER 1 PFP in boxing, no one should even question that.

[koolkc107]

Yeah but the winner Retired so the p4p #1 slot is open

I have several rated above both men P4P, most notably Crawford and Mikey.

I don't think a victory by either guy gets them past those two.

[iamboxing]

Poll options take longer to read than your post. I got sh\t to do.