Comments Thread For: Terence Crawford is The BWAA's Pound-For-Pound Number 1

[Deletrious]

Dropping Golovkin for the reason that he was robbed of a victory is laughably bad reasoning.

While their specific reasoning may be wrong, I do think it's tight at the top of the P4P and am not shocked some people have Crawdaddy up there.

[-DSG-]

Any list with Spence in the top 10 I can’t take serious.

[jas]

I cant argue with that

Crawford is gonna be very hard to beat. Hes very versatile. Sometimes starts slow though. Him vs spence who i have in the top 10 p4p also is an epic fight

[BigStomps]

Why does Canelo get so much credit for going the distance with GGG? Jacobs did much better against GGG & had a legitimate reason he won the fight! Before the GGG fight, Canelo's last five opponents where Chavez Jr(D-level), Liam Smith(D-level), Khan(C-B level @ 147), Cotto (C-B level), Kirkland(C-level)! That doesn't justify a top four rankings. Also, why is Kovalev still on the list after loosing back to back? Mikey Garcia is ranked to high after beating two bums at 135 & beating a mediocrity Broner! Thurman should be a few spots higher. Why isn't the fighter who beat Roman Gonzales TWICE not on the list? That shows that most p4p list are a popularity contest. Rigo should be higher but every fighter at his weight & 126(Dela Cruz, Frampton, Selby, Russell Jr and Mares all afraid to fight Rigo. Loma is really good & I'm a big fan of his but he only has 10 fights! I think eventually he will take over the number one spot but it will be hard to remove Terrence from the top spot.!

Jacobs did not do better against triple g than Canelo. I didn't see Canelo laid out on his back the way I saw Jacobs.
But I'm guessing your a black guy since your favoring black fighters.
Not surprised at all!

[Squ□redCircle34]

GGG just beat Canelo and got robbed with a DRAW, and you have Canelo 2 and GGG 9

Cack-sucking much?

IMO, Canelo beat GGG and got robbed with a draw!

Beating the man of 160 and the champ and the boogeyman of boxing and the division brought him into the top 5!

While GGG getting exposed as a very limited fighter showed that he can atleast hang a bit with an elite opponent so he comes out into the top 10 p4p!

Knowing you, you'd put GGG as the best boxer in the world at number 1! You and them GGG fanatics!

Swallowing much?! LOL

[Larry the boss]

i think that rigondeaux is listed too high and i don't think kovalev should be on there. If back-to-back losses including a stoppage are enough to oust gonzalez from the list then the same should go for him.

difference is kovalev lost to a fellow p4p fighter, while gonzalez lost to a no one

[Raggamuffin]

Thank God somebody got it right. Ward retired and Bud is now the pfp king.

[killer joe]

You missed the real joke. Pete Horn's name was nowhere on that list, not even the also mentioned list. And that ****ing bum has a title and possible ppv potential. Not that's a joke.

[chrisJS]

Thank God somebody got it right. Ward retired and Bud is now the pfp king.

Curious though. Is Gamboa-Postol-Indongo better than Walters-Russell-Rigo (if he wins) ?

Not that I disagree with the ranking, but I just want you to admit bias and discredit the Walters win for inactivity (despite Gamboa being more inactive) or the Rigo fight for size (despite Gamboa being much smaller also) and Indongo being better than Russell despite probably picking Russel (and Walters too I'm sure). Also to see Postol now be a great fighter after I'm sure being an overrated euro bum before the shut out loss.

Not my opinions, but the opinions of many here.

[Raggamuffin]

Curious though. Is Gamboa-Postol-Indongo better than Walters-Russell-Rigo (if he wins) ?

Not that I disagree with the ranking, but I just want you to admit bias and discredit the Walters win for inactivity (despite Gamboa being more inactive) or the Rigo fight for size (despite Gamboa being much smaller also) and Indongo being better than Russell despite probably picking Russel (and Walters too I'm sure). Also to see Postol now be a great fighter after I'm sure being an overrated euro bum before the shut out loss.

Not my opinions, but the opinions of many here.

Walters hadn't fought in a year and who did Russel Jr beat before he lost to Loma?

Bud has more wins than that and Bud hasnt lost. Loma won't get points for fighting a man moving up to fight him and Loma has lost and hasnt gained revenge.