Comments Thread For: Ward's Shock Exit Gives Chance To Others To Fill P4P Vacuum

[Gunpowdergreg]

As of today:

Terence crawford
vasyl lomachenko
guillermo rigondeaux
gennady golovkin
canelo alvarez
keith thurman
garry russell jr.
Mikey garcia
erroll spence jr.
Leo santa cruz

[UFC_Boxing]

1) Terence Crawford
2) best of: GGG-Canelo-Jacobs
3) Best of: Lomachenko-Rigondeau-M. Garcia
4) Best of: Spence - Thurman
5) A. Joshua

[aboutfkntime]

So how do we do this??? Based on the eye test against not soo good competititon??

Or

Based on actul REAL fights and pro resume??

the eye test, mostly..... 1) style 2) form 3) resume

this is not an ATG list

including resume is fine, because it adds that proven factor..... but this is a hypothetical conversation and there could be more relevant fighters emerging

if all things were equal (weight), then who would win ?

a P4P list takes knowledge/understanding

only using resume, means two things.....

1) you needed someone to draw you a roadmap
2) you likely failed to factor in style/form

for those who disagree.....
* the best current active resume is Pac, so make him #1
* completely remove Golovkin from your P4P list

the three best fighters in the world, do not have great resume's..... yet

ATG, or even "current ATG"..... is resume ONLY

[aboutfkntime]

As of today:

Terence crawford
vasyl lomachenko
guillermo rigondeaux
gennady golovkin
canelo alvarez
keith thurman
garry russell jr.
Mikey garcia
erroll spence jr.
Leo santa cruz

not the worst list I have seen

there really isn't much in it between some of those fighters

I got.....

1) Rigondeaux
2) Crawford
3) Lomachenko
4) Gonzales
5) Alvarez
6) Golovkin
7) Kovalev
8) Garcia
9) inoue
10) Spence

in truth, Garcia could be as high as 4

Inoue/Spence are on the up

[aboutfkntime]

By people who know Boxing, **** Boy. GGG chased coWard and Fraud out of Boxing. You're gonna have to find 2 new bean bags to suck on. **** Boy.

[IMG]https://media.*****.com/media/26FL3iy1fQG8K1YA0/*****.gif[/IMG]




[IMG]https://media.*****.com/media/l4JyRT7tsfigWU8kE/*****.gif[/IMG]




do you still run around telling stories about how you beat up Alfonso Gomez back when you were a 16yo MMA fighter? LOOOOOL

[Gunpowdergreg]

not the worst list I have seen

there really isn't much in it between some of those fighters

I got.....

1) Rigondeaux
2) Crawford
3) Lomachenko
4) Gonzales
5) Alvarez
6) Golovkin
7) Kovalev
8) Garcia
9) inoue
10) Spence

in truth, Garcia could be as high as 4

Inoue/Spence are on the up

I put a lot of thought into it but when it gets to 9&10 there are just so many guys on the cusp of the next level

[Shadoww702]

the eye test, mostly..... 1) style 2) form 3) resume

this is not an ATG list

including resume is fine, because it adds that proven factor..... but this is a hypothetical conversation and there could be more relevant fighters emerging

if all things were equal (weight), then who would win ?

a P4P list takes knowledge/understanding

only using resume, means two things.....

1) you needed someone to draw you a roadmap
2) you likely failed to factor in style/form

for those who disagree.....
* the best current active resume is Pac, so make him #1
* completely remove Golovkin from your P4P list

the three best fighters in the world, do not have great resume's..... yet

ATG, or even "current ATG"..... is resume ONLY

Ok! Then what about guys who are stepping up out of their "Comfort" zone to fight much bigger fighters??? Like say Mikey Garcia and Rig.? Against guys who sit and squat/dominate a weight class that isn't even really that good???

[aboutfkntime]

Ok! Then what about guys who are stepping up out of their "Comfort" zone to fight much bigger fighters??? Like say Mikey Garcia and Rig.? Against guys who sit and squat/dominate a weight class that isn't even really that good???

they have a distinct advantage

that is the very definition of P4P