Comments Thread For: Donaire Had Flashbacks Over Canelo-Golovkin Scoring By Byrd

[MDPopescu]

How do i give points in this site?

Why are you asking?... You've got none...

[BrometheusBob.]

I gave it to 7-5 Magdaleno. Donaire was a shadow of his former self in that fight.

I didn't score it but I thought Magdaleno took it clearly enough. The two 8-4 Magdaleno cards sounded good to me. A shame for Donaire who showed some good power in spots, like the 12th IIRC.

I remember the twitter scorecard had it 9-3 Donaire though

[Randall Cunning]

The difference in that case was that Magdaleno whooped Donaire easily. No way in hell did Donaire win that fight, I don't wanna hear that at all.

Yeah man. It dilutes the issue if every swinging **** starts complaining "Yeah that ***** gave 120-108 against me, I deserved at least the 118-110 the other judges gave"

[BrometheusBob.]

Yeah man. It dilutes the issue if every swinging **** starts complaining "Yeah that ***** gave 120-108 against me, I deserved at least the 118-110 the other judges gave"

LOL yeah that's what I'm getting at. Sure maybe 10-2 wasn't right in that fight but who cares. Point is all three judges scored for Magdaleno, which was the correct winner. The other two judges scorecards where different by only two rounds, not the end of the world.

Now 118-110 Canelo was crazy on the other hand, being that GGG probably should have won a close fight.

[Willy Wanker]

Donaire took a while to get settled in that fight. He looked sluggish and his power and snap to his punches wasn't there. He also predictable with his offense.

He did pick things up later in the fight, but it was too little too late. I remember having it close with Magdeleno winning clearly.

I had a feeling Magdeleno was gonna get robbed.

[asgarth]

The difference in that case was that Magdaleno whooped Donaire easily. No way in hell did Donaire win that fight, I don't wanna hear that at all.

Magdaleno was the better fighter that night and dished out far more punishment, but in terms of rounds I also had it 7-5 for magdaleno

[lowblows420]

Byrd is in someone's pocket probably NSAC as long Boxing stays corrupt they will never ever get a dollar from me I'll keep ripping fights on line

[WesternChamp]

The difference in that case was that Magdaleno whooped Donaire easily. No way in hell did Donaire win that fight, I don't wanna hear that at all.

Nobody is complaining that donaire won, read the damm article!!

Donaire is talking about the score card. 118-110 in the donaire fight and now 118-110 in the canelo fight.

[BrometheusBob.]

Nobody is complaining that donaire won, read the damm article!!

Donaire is talking about the score card. 118-110 in the donaire fight and now 118-110 in the canelo fight.

My point was that no one should even care about the scorecard possibly being too wide as it went to the right person.

[devildg]

i had Donaire winning that fight too, but it was a lot closer than Canelo-GGG

GGG won clearly while Donaire-Magdanelo was a legit draw or Donaire close win.