Canelo or JMM

[WesternChamp]

- Barrera
- Casamayor
- Katsidis
- Juan Diaz

Heck, I think Marquez gave Floyd a better fight than Canelo.

only name that matters.

[WesternChamp]

I like Canelo better. JMM was a better boxer, but Canelo doesn't cry and bytch endlessly, about everything.

not yet....

[PunchMeIDareYou]

Canelo is without a doubt the better all around fighter.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Other than durability, defense and fighting on the inside, Marquez is pretty much better at everything else.

[SilverMiles]

only name that matters.

He arguably lost that fight as well.

[microMXL]

He arguably lost that fight as well.

yeah, Barrera looked better in that fight, I don't remember the exact scorecards but there was a point deduction.

[TheBigLug]

Marquez for me, but i think we do tend to hold older/retired guys in more esteem.

[otrocubiche]

JMM so far, Canelo is still young and can be better.
JMM was my favorite fighter, I only wish he'd had a mute button.

[GhostofDempsey]

Marquez has the edge. He is a better counter-puncher and has deceptive quickness. Has more stamina too.