Is Castillo Officially a Cheater? PLZ Vote

[flipbjefrox]

Lightning doesnt strike twice..... tell that to Jose Luis Castillo. Knowing full well that Castillo failed to make weight again, do you still view his last minute effort of failing to make weight cheating. We all know what his doctor did by fooling with the scale. Knowing everything we know today, is castillo a cheater who knows he cant beat Diego at 135?

[ferocity]

no he isn't a cheater

[Kball15]

hes not a cheater, he just showed horrible sportsmanship, zero class, and no respect

[GunStar]

No doubt about it, he is a cheater.

[moy22487]

the first time with the foot in the scale yes that act was cheating.
him not being able to make weight, not cheating he just cant do it. ******ed move signing the contract but not cheating.

[GunStar]

hes not a cheater, he just showed horrible sportsmanship, zero class, and no respect

That makes him a cheater.

[ReadyUp]

That makes him a cheater.

No it doesn't, I think it was evident to everyone that if he came in even a 1/2 pound overweight that it was going to be a HUGE issue. But 5 pounds is unexcusable.

However, it doesn't make JLC a "cheater".
A huge embrassment FOR THE TIME BEING, yes.
But a cheater, no.

[Kball15]

That makes him a cheater.

not really. i guess u could call it cheating, but its more of an inability to do something. It was more like he didnt try and just hoped it would all work out then he cheated to get out of the fight.

[GunStar]

No it doesn't, I think it was evident to everyone that if he came in even a 1/2 pound overweight that it was going to be a HUGE issue. But 5 pounds is unexcusable.

However, it doesn't make JLC a "cheater".
A huge embrassment FOR THE TIME BEING, yes.
But a cheater, no.

He was planning to cheat again.

[moy22487]

He was planning to cheat again.

if he had try to made it look like he was making weight then it would of been cheating