Higher P4P, Lomachenko or Rigondeaux?

[A.K]

With all the talk of a Lomachenko-Rigondeaux fight, I thought I'd ask who's better P4P. On one hand, Lomachenko has done more recently. But, Rigondeaux still has the better individual win in Donaire.

Walters knocked donaire out he was ranked higher than donaire ever was on p4p so no Loma has the better wins in Walters and Russell jr.

[Metho_4u]

Rigo

He's clearly the better fighter.

How so? What's he done to prove that?

[HarvardBlue]

Rigo by one Donaire. Better win than anything Lomachenko has done so far. In-house quitting doesn't count.

[Lester Tutor]

Rigo by one Donaire. Better win than anything Lomachenko has done so far. In-house quitting doesn't count.

Damn, good one. Rigo did in house star wrecking

[dan_cov]

Walters knocked donaire out he was ranked higher than donaire ever was on p4p so no Loma has the better wins in Walters and Russell jr.

Donaire was a top 3 p4p fighter when Rigo beat him. A 3 weight world champion, undefeated for a decade. Has Walters even cracked top 10 P4P?
The only noteworthy win Walters has is vs Donaire who was never the same or anywhere near as effective at the weight. Walters then proceeded to have two poor outings before being sat on the shelf for a full year.

And who the ****s Gary Russell Jr beaten? a 90yr old Gonzalez? He got fast hands doe.

[dan_cov]

One guy fights and is expected to fight guys 12-15lbs bigger than him the other fights and is expected to fight guys 12-15lbs smaller.

[Dinamita 03]

One guy fights and is expected to fight guys 12-15lbs bigger than him the other fights and is expected to fight guys 12-15lbs smaller.

What? Bit of a hyperbole there.


Marriaga is the only guy he's ever fought out of his weight class. He just fought a massive dude in Walters.

As far as P4P, both are extremely talented, but i'd put Lomachenko ahead.

[soul_survivor]

Explain how Rigo is p4p in 2017.

[redmish]

Lomachenko. It's not even close. You can't put rigo in there based on recent inactivity. He is class though and hopefully the big fights happen.

[GhostofDempsey]

I would rate Loma's wins over Russell Jr. and Walters over Rigo's win of Donaire. Loma is a two division champion and has seven title defenses in just ten fights. Not even close.