would edwin valero be p4p number 1 if he was still alive?

[dibzvincent143]

Im inclined to agree with demarco. What do people think?

Nobody would know for sure, but he definitely had a huge punchers chance over anyone even over elites like pacman.
At 130 I'd be more confident for marquez to go against him than pacquiao, pac makes too much mistakes but used to have the chin to absorb the powers of all he has fought, against valero at 130 i doubt that.
Marquez feints, patience and counterpunching meanwhile would be more effective against a come forward southpaw.
At 140-145, then its pacquiao.
At any weight, floyd schools him.