would edwin valero be p4p number 1 if he was still alive?

[bluebeam]

nope.......

[HarvardBlue]

Valero was pretty basic. He had good power and an exceptional work rate but he was also lacking in fundamentals.

I actually thought he would be able to beat Pacquiao after the DeMarco fight then I went and watched his earlier fights and changed my mind quickly.

[*TonyMontana*]

yeah true, and with his style he was gonna get in a few wars for sure. I think he would hve got to the top but not sure how long he'd have been there for.

Just one of those things

Nobody will ever know bud

[DoktorSleepless]

Boxing was born before any of us
We are all playing catch up

True.

no offence taken, but ive been a fan of the sport for many years now, just rewatching one of his highlight vids. Was watching valero on the way up back in the day...

I ask because back when I started posting in 2010, I came in as a Sergio Martinez fan boy and wasn't a huge follower of the sport. Then I started branching out and watching older fights, and started making threads about them because I was curious about people's opinions. I got the same sort impression with you because when you first started posting it was all Golovkin I think.

[JoeKidd]

Remember Lucas Matthysse? The invincible one?

[The Time]

One word answer..............Nope

[PACnPBFsuck]

He wasn't even allowed to fight in the states, so no.

[HanzGruber]

Lmao no....

[Madison Boxing]

True.



I ask because back when I started posting in 2010, I came in as a Sergio Martinez fan boy and wasn't a huge follower of the sport. Then I started branching out and watching older fights, and started making threads about them because I was curious about people's opinions. I got the same sort impression with you because when you first started posting it was all Golovkin I think.

nah been following it a long time, morales, calzaghe, marquez are my favourites. I still post a lot about golovkin

[SN!PER]

He would've beat Khan but would've lost to Pacquiao and Cotto.