Who do you guys think would win this Round Robin Tournament?

[Blu]

At 154 who do you guys think would win this round-robin tournament:


- Floyd Mayweather Jr
- Manny Pacquiao
- Saul Alvarez
- Sergio Martinez
- Gennady Golovkin
- Oscar De la Hoya

Also place them in what you think their final rank would have been by the end of the tournament, who came in first, second, last, etc.

[Blu]

bump!

please respond, amigos.

[CinderelliMan]

Im what people on this site would call a GGGtard so I may be a little bias but I would have GGG KOing that whole list on route to meeting Floyd in the finals.

Floyd is Floyd and its kinda hard to bet against the guy but Id go with my heart and assume Golovkin would catch him somewhere in the 12 rounds and that would end the night and maybe many more for floyd.

[The Ninth Layer]

Are we talking about who would win TODAY or are we talking about these fighters at their primes?

[iamboxing]

Has to be Mayweather, his boxing IQ is astronomical compared to those listed and that's not taking away from my favourite fighter right now GGG

[Blu]

Are we talking about who would win TODAY or are we talking about these fighters at their primes?

Well, all their primes were basically at different weight classes, for example Sergio was his best at 160, but for the sake of argument lets just say they are all in their prime at 154.

[The Ninth Layer]

Well, all their primes were basically at different weight classes, for example Sergio was his best at 160, but for the sake of argument lets just say they are all in their prime at 154.

In that case:

#1 Mayweather
#2 GGG
#3 Pacquiao
#4 Martinez
#5 Canelo
#6 ODLH

Although it's very close. I think a prime and ready Mayweather (say the one who fought Cotto in 2011) would handle all but GGG and Pacquiao without too much trouble, and I think in the end he would beat both Golovkin and Pacquiao in close fights.

I have GGG above Pacquiao mostly because of size differences. Pacquiao at 154 lb would get busted up.

The last three spots are all subjective, I don't think there's a ton separating them. Prime Martinez was a fantastic boxer though who I think would box circles around Canelo and Oscar. I think Manny and Golovkin would both give Martinez a hard time and I dunno if he could starch either of them like he did Williams.

Prime Oscar is hard to evaluate compared to the others, he fought Mayweather and Pacquiao way too late in his career and may have given them both hell when he was younger, but it's hard to say. I also think Canelo is hard to evaluate against the others since he's arguably the only one of these fighters with room to develop.

[eco1]

glolovkin 1
Martinez 2

[MASTERBX]

If lil g can enter this tournament so can Ward, I got Ward beating them all.

[elfag]

1. floyd
2. canelo
3. ggg
4. sergio
5. pac
6. dlh