Spence is top 5 p4p

[TMTForever99]

1. Andre ward
2. guillermo rigondeaux
3. Keith Thurman
4. Terence Crawford
5. Errol Spence
6. Gervonta Davis
7. Mikey Garcia
8. Jermall Charlo
9. Canelo Alvarez
10. Vasily Lomanchecko

[Sheldon312]

no, he isn't. he just got his first meaningful victory over a guy that was coming from taking a bad beating 2 weight classes above and still gave him a hard fight.

But you place Loma and Crawford higher when neither one have a boxer of Brook's caliber on their list.

[Dean_Razorback]

But you place Loma and Crawford higher when neither one have a boxer of Brook's caliber on their list.

the way loma dispatched walters and crawford postol and diaz put them ahead of spence.

[Willy Wanker]

He's in the argument for top 10, but definitely not top 5.

Not yet.

[A.K]

P4P top 5

#1 Ward
#2 Crawford
#3 Spence
#4 Charlo
#5 Wilder

ward number 1 lmaoooo and charlo who one day could be but has too crap of a resume right now, and wilder doesnt belong anywhere near a p4p put down the crack pipe bruh loma is on top followed by golovkin.

[Sheldon312]

the way loma dispatched walters and crawford postol and diaz put them ahead of spence.

Brook is a way better win than Diaz and Postol. Brook os just a better fighter. I dont see how walters, Diaz, and Postol are better wins than beating brook.

[Dean_Razorback]

Brook is a way better win than Diaz and Postol. Brook os just a better fighter. I dont see how walters, Diaz, and Postol are better wins than beating brook.

whatever you want man. those 3 guys were unbeaten (diaz was robbed vs peterson) walters is a KO artist, loma made him look silly. postol was coming from KOing lucas and diaz is an olympic gold medallist and crawford didn't even break a sweat.

[bballchump11]

**** idk about top 5, but I have to seriously consider top 10. If he beats Thurman, I'll skyrocket him toward the top.

[Poppo168]

1. Andre ward
2. guillermo rigondeaux - nope
3. Keith Thurman
4. Terence Crawford
5. Errol Spence - ??
6. Gervonta Davis - lol what?
7. Mikey Garcia
8. Jermall Charlo
9. Canelo Alvarez
10. Vasily Lomanchecko

I agree with some of your list, but a few stand out points highlighted.

How can Davis be 5th when he's got 1 okay win on his resume & Loma in 10th

[Sheldon312]

whatever you want man. those 3 guys were unbeaten (diaz was robbed vs peterson) walters is a KO artist, loma made him look silly. postol was coming from KOing lucas and diaz is an olympic gold medallist and crawford didn't even break a sweat.

Still Brook is better than all those guys.