Castillo vs Mayweather

[El Gitano]

He clearly won the 1st fight

Nope. You can believe he won the first fight, but clearly? No way. I thought, and you know that most people believe Castillo won the first fight. No debate. Even the last poll I saw here at boxingscene, 69% of forum member voters believe Castillo won vs just 31% that believe Floyd won.

https://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=576019

[HeadShots]

a lot of Mayweather's fights are up for debate.

He has terrible ring generalship for the most part and he's allowed to foul in any way shape or form. of course hometown refs.



Would Mayweather get the decision in Argentina against Maidana? nope.

Would Mayweather get the decision against Castillo in Mexico both times? nope.

[SkillspayBills]

The situations are completely different. Both GGG and Floyd are going for the higher money option, that's the only similarity. Floyd fighting madiana and castillo again made the most sense at the time. Maidana sold a lot of tickets as he is exciting.

Stop assuming the situations are identical as they are very different in nature.

You are a dirty disgusting hypocrite. I absolutely abhor users like you. Sitting their on your ass making EXCUSES on why GGG shouldn't face criticism for not facing Jacobs while at the same time justifying Floyd doing so. They are VERY similar and you not acknowledging that fact is deplorable. Can't stand hypocrisy on this site and the users guilty of it.

[Real King Kong]

lets see your round by round scorecard..i posted the entire fight

That's cuz you obviously don't have anything to do. I'm at work man...I'm not gonna just watch castillo vs mayweather. I've seen the fight at least 5 times...i thought castillo won.

[No Tomorrow]

I scored this fight years ago (115-111, FM, Jr.)

I think a fight that should be scored by a community of Boxing fans is Mayweather, Jr./Maidana I. I think that fight arguably could have been scored a draw.

[IronDanHamza]

48-1

fact

I think the term "fact" may be elluding you.

[493dart]

a lot of mayweather's fights are up for debate.

He has terrible ring generalship for the most part and he's allowed to foul in any way shape or form. Of course hometown refs.



Would mayweather get the decision in argentina against maidana? Nope.

Would mayweather get the decision against castillo in mexico both times? Nope.

exactly .