Comments Thread For: Is Lomachenko The Best Pound-for-Pound Fighter in Boxing?

[Cutthroat]

Not impressed with his best W, Walters. He needs a Garcia on his resume to even be considered #1.

Walters didn't carry his power up in weight and that was evident against Sosa. He was also shelved for a year, I don't consider it a quality win. His performance was dominant but Walters without his power is just a meh type of fighter.

Russel Jr, this dude was called "TBA" on this forum for years, Loma beats him, suddenly he's legit lol

[gmc_rfc_06]

Yep, he's the best fighter in the sport.

Only trouble I can see him having is getting the big fights. As we know, guys tend to avoid the hardest fights instead opting for easier money.

[Metho_4u]

SO BEATING ROMAN MARTINEZ AND SOSA BACK TO BACK IS HUUUUGE AND MAKES YOU P4P KING.... BUT BEATING PORTER AND DANNY GARCIA BACK TO BACK BARELY GETS YOU A MENTION ON THE P4P RANKINGS???? SOMETHING IS NOT ADDING UP.....

Only thing is, the later got close decisions on both, not a total domination...and why did you leave walters and Russell out? Both were schooled, one quit. The kind may not be #1, but he's got the skills imo.

[Metho_4u]

Not impressed with his best W, Walters. He needs a Garcia on his resume to even be considered #1.

Walters didn't carry his power up in weight and that was evident against Sosa. He was also shelved for a year, I don't consider it a quality win. His performance was dominant but Walters without his power is just a meh type of fighter.

Russel Jr, this dude was called "TBA" on this forum for years, Loma beats him, suddenly he's legit lol

He wasn't shelved for a year, he was offered the fight 6 months before it actually happened and walters turned it down. I cannot see how that is lomachencho's problem? There was also a lot of people picking walters by ko as well.

[SkillspayBills]

Andre Ward is. He's the only one in the top 5 that's actually beaten another member of the P4P list. Loma is working his way up there though

[-DSG-]

He easily is.

[killakali]

SO BEATING ROMAN MARTINEZ AND SOSA BACK TO BACK IS HUUUUGE AND MAKES YOU P4P KING.... BUT BEATING PORTER AND DANNY GARCIA BACK TO BACK BARELY GETS YOU A MENTION ON THE P4P RANKINGS???? SOMETHING IS NOT ADDING UP.....

u mean beating Nicholas Walters and Sosa back to back. Remember Rocky was before that.

Also remember that some people think Porter Beat thurman

[MEXfistology]

No he is not...his resume is too weak, he's not even top 5.., top 15 maybe

[Mr. 29K]

This is the reason why boxing is becoming a joke. They want to put a bum who got whooped by Salido as the #1 P4P? Lol.

WARd is #1. No question about it. Lomabumko is like #11. Pathetic writers.

[Godsfly]

This is the reason why boxing is becoming a joke. They want to put a bum who got whooped by Salido as the #1 P4P? Lol.

WARd is #1. No question about it. Lomabumko is like #11. Pathetic writers.

he's not a bum.......he has amazing talent. but to say that lomachenko is p4p 1 is also very ******ed and just people forcing it at that point. rather then force just let the guy pave his greatness and way.

russell, sosa, walters don't = pfp 1

hell. crawfords....gamboa, postol, Beltran, Burns head and shoulders above lomachenkos resume. but even i don't put him at p4p number 1.

also thurman does have a argument to be higher then lomachenko. i like his wins against a solid porter, garcia, Guerrero. it's close. with a peterson win it solidifies him for me.