Has Thurman earned a top 10 P4P ranking?

[P.K Dionysus]

All I need from Keith is activity personally.

At least two more fights this year will be good.

[b00g13man]

I won't argue at no 10. Any higher, and I'd probably have something to say.

[MDPopescu]

I don't think it matters where Thurman is ranked p4p right now -- he did his job.

[Damn Wicked]

I disagree. He needs to clean out 147. Winning close decisions against your peers is not p4p material. Danny is no kovalev or ward. I don't see how that's a p4p performance.

Mayweather won many close decisions.

But you're right about Danny not deserving top 10 p4p status. He's agood fighter, a strong fighter but he's too flawed to be p4p.

P4P is all imaginary anyway. It means nothing.

[bojangles1987]

I won't argue about it. Outside of the top 5 or 6, there's a lot of uncertainty and Thurman can land a spot.

[original zero]

By unifying the WBC & WBA titles, Thurman moved up to #2 on my P4P list (I have GGG #1).

They're the only fighters who hold the top two titles in their division.

[Damn Wicked]

I won't argue about it. Outside of the top 5 or 6, there's a lot of uncertainty and Thurman can land a spot.

That's a reasonable statement.

[NEETzsche]

He's not even #1 in his division yet, so no

If he beats Brook/Spence or Pacquiao, then there should be a place for him

[original zero]

He's not even #1 in his division yet, so no

If he beats Brook/Spence or Pacquiao, then there should be a place for him

he's the champion of the top two organizations in boxing. you may not have him #1 in your personal rankings, but in the sport of boxing he is the #1 champion of his division.

[NEETzsche]

he's the champion of the top two organizations in boxing. you may not have him #1 in your personal rankings, but in the sport of boxing he is the #1 champion of his division.

According to who? What has Garcia done at welterweight to be the kingmaker?

Pacquiao was #2, then Floyd retired and he became #1. No one has unseated him yet. Brook got to Porter before Thurman did and beat him clearer, and his next opponent is certainly no worse than Garcia

147 is still wide open. Last night was a nice match-up but it was still just a fight between two top 10s, not #1 vs #2 or even #2 vs #3