Has Thurman earned a top 10 P4P ranking?

[A.K]

Yes he has , but Spence would have easy ways with anyone at 147.

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

That's your opinion and they're not the same weight. What if Mayweather was heavyweight. You can't even bring that **** up, Keith Thurman would have different style if he was in another weight class

Mate, do you know the definition of P4P?

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

No....

He is a jack of all trades, master of none type fighter... nowhere near the level of Roman, ggg, Ward, rigo, loma

He said top 10 not top 5.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

They might be. But they don't have a resume to back it up. Unless you don't include resume at all in pfp

I do but I also gotta take skills into consideration...

Thurman has the resume,, I'm not dis*****g that, I just don't think he is one of the top 10 guys in the world.. Spence might destroy this dude..

[HanzGruber]

This. He needs to rematch and beat porter and then fight Spence/brook to Crack top 10. And Danny was on nobodies p4p lists for a reason. Was good at 140 then came bogus decisions to Herrera and others. Then got a vacant belt at 147 that he didn't earn and zero wins against top welterweights.

Brook has a more legit win against porter and Herrera beat Danny and neither of them are p4p.

Wtf is this. He needs to beat Porter again and the. Brook Spence just to crack top 10? Frampton was top 10 for beating quigg and Leo. Porter and Danny are better than both of them.

People didn't have Danny cause he's one of the most hated on this site. Hell people didn't even wanna add him after he beat lucas. Both Danny and Thurman were top 15 pfp before tonight

[Sugar Adam Ali]

He said top 10 not top 5.

Ward
Kovolev
Roman
Manny
Rigo
Ggg
Canelo
Crawford
Mikey
Loma
Bradley
Estrada
Brook
Spence
Stevenson
Lara
Charlo

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Wtf is this. He needs to beat Porter again and the. Brook Spence just to crack top 10? Frampton was top 10 for beating quigg and Leo. Porter and Danny are better than both of them.

People didn't have Danny cause he's one of the most hated on this site. Hell people didn't even wanna add him after he beat lucas. Both Danny and Thurman were top 15 pfp before tonight

Because he didn't really belong on there. Just look at what he did after beating Matthysse. Nothing...

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

Ward
Kovolev
Roman
Manny
Rigo
Ggg
Canelo
Crawford
Mikey
Loma
Bradley
Estrada
Brook
Spence
Stevenson
Lara
Charlo

Estrada? Lara? Stevenson? Spence? Like Hanz said, unless you don't include resume then there's no reason for not having Thurman AT LEAST 10th.

And even if you don't include resume, you really think Bradley is better than Thurman?

[.:: JSFD26 ::.]

He is a jack of all trades, master of none type fighter

Thurman is a great action fighter, but his skills are not the greatest and not elite... his greatest asset is his will to win and heart IMO

The very same arguments you made about Thurman can be made about Bradley but you have him above Thurman.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Estrada? Lara? Stevenson? Spence? Like Hanz said, unless you don't include resume then there's no reason for not having Thurman AT LEAST 10th.

And even if you don't include resume, you really think Bradley is better than Thurman?

So right now you would take Thurman over Spence???