Comments Thread For: DiBella: Thurman vs. Garcia Will Decide The Top Dog at 147

[koolbreez12]

Based on resume Pac and Bradley are head and shoulders the best in the division now that Money May has retired.

The young guns Thurman, Spence are finally getting major fights.

Brook has one good quality win and Garcia is finally fighting a real welterweight.

It's an eliminator but not quite prove who's the best in the division.

I agree with this assessment completely.

[Strategic1]

that said, if garcia beats thurman, he'll have the biggest win in recent years among the current ww's.

I agree with that. Especially since the fight is between 2 top 10 welters with no clear favorite.

Other ones..
Pac vs Bradley (no surprise, Pac was clear favorite)
Bradley vs JMM
Thurman-Porter

What is nice about 2017 so far... it seems like there will be great fights at 147 this year.

[JASON SHAW]

MEANWHILE MANNY THE CHERRYPICKER IS FIGHTING DANNY GARCIAS LEFTOVERS...... YAWNNNNNNNN THANK GOD FOR PBC AND THEIR FREE AMAZING CARDS...... GOLDEN GIRL AND TOP PRANKS PPV MISMATCHES ARE KILLING BOXING.....

[mrlopez]

Manny n Tim

are still the best in the division. Theyre definitely older but still #1 n #2 respectively. I'll rank the winner of Thurman/Garcia #3, Brook #4, loser of Thurman/Garcia #5 and Spence #6 as of right now.

[richardt]

No, the top dog would be determined by the winner of this fight going against the winner of the Brook / Spence fight and tossing Pac in there somewhere. Whoever wins between those 5 fighters, is the king of 147.

[-DSG-]

Nah winner still needs to beat PAC to claim the throne at 147.

[The Gambler1981]

I do definitely think you need to include Manny in the mix and probably the winner of Brook-Spence.

[original zero]

No, Spence vs Brook will. Either Spence or Brook beats both these guys.

who you think would win is not the same as who has accomplished the most.

undefeated WBC vs undefeated WBA trumps IBF coming off a loss vs unproven prospect.

[Jubei]

Keep creating your own reality lol. Manny shits on both of them, Brook after he beats Spence too.

[FLY TY]

are still the best in the division. Theyre definitely older but still #1 n #2 respectively. I'll rank the winner of Thurman/Garcia #3, Brook #4, loser of Thurman/Garcia #5 and Spence #6 as of right now.

Tim bradley is not top 5. I respect the guy's toughness and all that, but his ww resume is boo boo, and he's not active enough. He hasn't fought in a year, and i haven't heard any talk of him fighting anytime soon.

If we're going to **** on Manny for not taking tough fights anymore, then idk what to say about bradley, who fights the same guys manny does, but a lot less often.