A P4P Record

[Canelo and GGG]

Ok, thanks for the explanation. I can't hate on you if you have him in there for your reasons as these lists are our personal opinions.

What do you think is next for Cotto and who would you like to see him fight?

if he is not going back to 147 maybe some CW with one of top WWs ,154 i would see him with younger Charlo or Williams ,rematch with Nelo is possible cuse his 36 and looking to Cash out ,Maybe Bradley or Khan ?

he have lots of possiblites after beating krikland (i assume he will beat him)

[daggum]

His last fight was vs top P4P opponent and he had good showing ,i would say that he was in the best form in his life during Canelo fight ,Physicaly he looked phenomenal (Roach hand) and boxed very smart avoiding KO,there is no evidence that he is worse now then he was in Canelo fight.

luck of contenters to P4P list makes Cotto stay for me ,if i would count Pac he would be close to top too ,just weak moment ,you can make list with 1 or 2 wins at the moment ,many things will change this year.

is this some kind of new standard that boxing fans have? oh he didnt get ko'd how great.

[Canelo and GGG]

is this some kind of new standard that boxing fans have? oh he didnt get ko'd how great.

Maybe i put it wrong ,he not only avoided KO ,but was boxing to win to the end ,gave very competeive fight with top p4p fighter not first time in his careere ,also beat judah in his prime ,and Mosley ,now i know it was long time ago but Cotto didnt show a sign of slowing down ,if anything he improved ,his not chinny anymore and have expirience on highest lvl you can.

[BM dnobagaV]

How do 2 people have Bradley above Pacquiao..................

[Canelo and GGG]

How do 2 people have Bradley above Pacquiao..................

im not counting Pac in my list.

[soul_survivor]

1.Ward/Kovalev
2.Alvarez
3.Gonzales
4.Bradley
5.Garcia
6.Estrada
7.Cotto (probably still beats everybody in 147)
8.GGG
9.Crawford
10.Inoue

Both resume and eye test

Yeah, if you'ren ot putting a time limit on resume, then Cotto could still be on any p4p list plus he did look very good in his last fight. I felt Cotto won and its clear from the judges cards the yhadn o intention o fscoring it fairly. If one is to score it for Canelo, it would still be close.

I think those judges gave Canelo 10 and 11 rounds....so Cotto won 1 or 2 rounds at most lol Thats ridiculous.

Cotto should have pursued an immediate rematch but he never did.

How do 2 people have Bradley above Pacquiao..................

maybe due to Manny's retirement? I assume most would have taken him off their lists by that point

[Canelo and GGG]

Yeah, if you'ren ot putting a time limit on resume, then Cotto could still be on any p4p list plus he did look very good in his last fight. I felt Cotto won and its clear from the judges cards the yhadn o intention o fscoring it fairly. If one is to score it for Canelo, it would still be close.

I think those judges gave Canelo 10 and 11 rounds....so Cotto won 1 or 2 rounds at most lol Thats ridiculous.

Cotto should have pursued an immediate rematch but he never did.



maybe due to Manny's retirement? I assume most would have taken him off their lists by that point

I have no problem with counting resume when i see that someone is not dropping off ,Cotto showed no such thing.

Ofc in case of RJJ or Mosley they resume dont mean **** in P4P talk now ,you know what i mean

[KingHippo]

Ok, so its a new year, a new dawn etc so I want everyone who wants to, to post their top 10 p4p lists on here and we can thus keep a record of how people are ranking fighters and how those rankings change through the course of the year (so obviously post updated lists when changes are reuqired or you feel are necessary).

This is not necessarily a thread to discuss the validity of each list but rather how thesel ists are put together and what you hold to be your criteria. And ofc a record of how it will change over the course of the year (if at all)

Mine is as thus:

1. Sergey Kovalev
2. Roman Gonzalez
3. Gennady Golovkin
4. Saul Alvarez
5. Vasyl Lomachenko
6. Terence Crawford
7. Manny Pacquiao
8. Naoya Inoue
9. Shinsuke Yamanaka
10. Juan Francisco Estrada

This list is dumb as ****. If you're gonna be a cheerleader, don't try to make it sound objective.

[koolkc107]

1) Ward
1B) Kovalev
3) Gonzalez
4) Crawford
5) M. Garcia
6) Spence
7) Rigondeaux
8) Pacquiao
9) Lomachenko
10) Alvarez

[soul_survivor]

I have no problem with counting resume when i see that someone is not dropping off ,Cotto showed no such thing.

Ofc in case of RJJ or Mosley they resume dont mean **** in P4P talk now ,you know what i mean

Yeah I get you