My top 9 P4P List

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • satiev1
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Nov 2015
    • 4661
    • 575
    • 0
    • 78,492

    #1

    My top 9 P4P List

    All these fighters below are very dominant in their own weight class. The criteria I use is skill, dominance among your peers, and resume. Note this is my order, but you can put these fighters in any order you see fit as long as they are in the top 9. I can't put any welterweights on the list because no one has established clear dominance and I can't put any hw's on the list either since no one has cleaned out the division. Number 10 is a pick em. You can make a case for the below fighters.

    1. Golovkin
    2. Andre Ward
    3. Sergey Kovalev
    4. Terrence Crawford
    5. Lomachenko
    6. Canelo Alvarez
    7. Roman Gonzalez
    8. Rigondeaux
    9. Mikey Garcia
    10. Errol Spence jr, Beterbiev, Stevenson, Anthony Joshua,or Fury, Inoue or Andrade.
  • TMTForever99
    Contender
    Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
    • Jan 2017
    • 288
    • 15
    • 46
    • 18,459

    #2
    my top 10 p4p list:

    1. Andre Ward - Unified 175 champion
    2. Guillermo Rigondeux - WBA super batnaweight champion
    3. Adonis Stevenson - Lineal WBC 175 champion on 12 ko streak
    4. Terence Crawford - Unified champion at 140lbs
    5. Keith Thurman - WBA champion at 147
    6. Canelo Alvarez - WBO chanpion at 154
    7. Errol Spence JR.- 12 fight ko strek hardest hitter at 147
    8. Vasyl lomanchenko - WBA champion at 130
    9. Daniel Jacobs - WBA champion at 160 12 fight ko streak
    10. Mikey Garcia- WBC 135 champion

    Comment

    • 1hourRun
      SQUAD-UP!
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Dec 2010
      • 20526
      • 2,789
      • 2,336
      • 140,312

      #3
      Originally posted by satiev1
      All I can't put any welterweights on the list because no one has established clear dominance.

      1. Golovkin
      2. Andre Ward
      3. Sergey Kovalev
      4. Terrence Crawford
      5. Lomachenko
      6. Canelo Alvarez
      7. Roman Gonzalez
      8. Rigondeaux
      9. Mikey Garcia
      10. Errol Spence jr, Beterbiev, Stevenson, Anthony Joshua,or Fury, Inoue or Andrade.
      Your reason to exclude a welterweight is flawed ; you got names up there that have not cleaned out their divisions or claimed the lineage as Pacman has at 147...and you talk about resume? Pacs accomplishments in the sport is far greater than most included on your list.

      Comment

      • 1hourRun
        SQUAD-UP!
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Dec 2010
        • 20526
        • 2,789
        • 2,336
        • 140,312

        #4
        Originally posted by TMTForever99
        my top 10 p4p list:

        1. Andre Ward - Unified 175 champion
        2. Guillermo Rigondeux - WBA super batnaweight champion
        3. Adonis Stevenson - Lineal WBC 175 champion on 12 ko streak
        4. Terence Crawford - Unified champion at 140lbs
        5. Keith Thurman - WBA champion at 147
        6. Canelo Alvarez - WBO chanpion at 154
        7. Errol Spence JR.- 12 fight ko strek hardest hitter at 147
        8. Vasyl lomanchenko - WBA champion at 130
        9. Daniel Jacobs - WBA champion at 160 12 fight ko streak
        10. Mikey Garcia- WBC 135 champion
        Your list is worse.

        Comment

        • Robbie Barrett
          Banned
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Nov 2013
          • 40891
          • 2,779
          • 667
          • 570,921

          #5
          Any P4P list that takes resume into account shouldn't have Golovkin anywhere near #1.

          Comment

          • A.K
            Undisputed Champion
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • May 2014
            • 11052
            • 280
            • 79
            • 71,066

            #6
            What has rigo done the last few years he isn't p4p

            Comment

            • SterlingStained
              Banned
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Jun 2013
              • 7671
              • 540
              • 581
              • 12,311

              #7
              Originally posted by TMTForever99
              my top 10 p4p list:

              1. Andre Ward - Unified 175 champion
              2. Guillermo Rigondeux - WBA super batnaweight champion
              3. Adonis Stevenson - Lineal WBC 175 champion on 12 ko streak
              4. Terence Crawford - Unified champion at 140lbs
              5. Keith Thurman - WBA champion at 147
              6. Canelo Alvarez - WBO chanpion at 154
              7. Errol Spence JR.- 12 fight ko strek hardest hitter at 147
              8. Vasyl lomanchenko - WBA champion at 130
              9. Daniel Jacobs - WBA champion at 160 12 fight ko streak
              10. Mikey Garcia- WBC 135 champion

              Comment

              • .:: JSFD26 ::.
                Brawski
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Mar 2012
                • 33329
                • 725
                • 432
                • 44,762

                #8
                Originally posted by satiev1
                All these fighters below are very dominant in their own weight class. The criteria I use is skill, dominance among your peers, and resume. Note this is my order, but you can put these fighters in any order you see fit as long as they are in the top 9. I can't put any welterweights on the list because no one has established clear dominance and I can't put any hw's on the list either since no one has cleaned out the division. Number 10 is a pick em. You can make a case for the below fighters.

                1. Golovkin
                2. Andre Ward
                3. Sergey Kovalev
                4. Terrence Crawford
                5. Lomachenko
                6. Canelo Alvarez
                7. Roman Gonzalez
                8. Rigondeaux
                9. Mikey Garcia
                10. Errol Spence jr, Beterbiev, Stevenson, Anthony Joshua,or Fury, Inoue or Andrade.
                Gonzalez #7 just barely above Rigo. Golovkin #1.
                Originally posted by TMTForever99
                my top 10 p4p list:

                1. Andre Ward - Unified 175 champion
                2. Guillermo Rigondeux - WBA super batnaweight champion
                3. Adonis Stevenson - Lineal WBC 175 champion on 12 ko streak
                4. Terence Crawford - Unified champion at 140lbs
                5. Keith Thurman - WBA champion at 147
                6. Canelo Alvarez - WBO chanpion at 154
                7. Errol Spence JR.- 12 fight ko strek hardest hitter at 147
                8. Vasyl lomanchenko - WBA champion at 130
                9. Daniel Jacobs - WBA champion at 160 12 fight ko streak
                10. Mikey Garcia- WBC 135 champion
                Originally posted by 1hourRun
                Your list is worse.
                Mikey Garcia and Rigo but no Gonzalez. These guy HAVE GOT TO be trolling.

                I just noticed Thurman too. LOL

                Comment

                • ////
                  ////
                  Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                  • Sep 2014
                  • 14948
                  • 952
                  • 671
                  • 111,577

                  #9
                  Originally posted by TMTForever99
                  my top 10 p4p list:

                  1. Andre Ward - Unified 175 champion
                  2. Guillermo Rigondeux - WBA super batnaweight champion
                  3. Adonis Stevenson - Lineal WBC 175 champion on 12 ko streak
                  4. Terence Crawford - Unified champion at 140lbs
                  5. Keith Thurman - WBA champion at 147
                  6. Canelo Alvarez - WBO chanpion at 154
                  7. Errol Spence JR.- 12 fight ko strek hardest hitter at 147
                  8. Vasyl lomanchenko - WBA champion at 130
                  9. Daniel Jacobs - WBA champion at 160 12 fight ko streak
                  10. Mikey Garcia- WBC 135 champion
                  stevenson has never belonged in the top 10. even when boxing was so dry that beating a horrifically washed up chad dawson made him the new p4p messiah he didn't belong anywhere near it.

                  flat out refused to fight the top 3-4 guys at 175 over the course of 5 years.

                  Comment

                  • bluebeam
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Feb 2009
                    • 3839
                    • 121
                    • 0
                    • 31,012

                    #10
                    1.Ward/Kovalev
                    2.Canelo
                    3.Golovkin
                    4.Gonzalez
                    5.Crawford
                    6.Pacquiao
                    7.Lomachenko
                    8.Rigondeaux
                    9.Mikey
                    10.danny/thurman

                    P4P

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP