Who do you have higher P4P, Canelo or Golovkin?

[soul_survivor]

GGG and its not a contest in reality. Canelo's best wins ARE better than GGGs but the way he has won those fights is suspect at times (I feel he lost to Cotto and barely got by Trout) but GGG has battered everyone in front him, showing he is levels above everyone in his division. Thats what a p4p fighters supposed to do.

[bambam182]

How dare you besmirch the great and historical weight class of Caneloweight. The only class in history that fluctuates!

HAHAH yeah like how pac used to always have catchweights also. catchweight manny.

[bambam182]

its a duck its a duck its a duck its a clear duck.

i need to make a song using that as a chorus making fun of you ****.

when i do that chorus is going to have some heavy drumming.

its a duck its a duck its a duck its a clear duck.
its a duck its a duck its a duck its a clear duck.

ducking ducking ducking ducking
"5 guys want to fight you, you fight 1 and your ducking the other 4"

thats another lyric added right there.

this song will be called "Ducking Boys"

making fun of all of you.

[bojangles1987]

Golovkin. Alvarez has better wins, but only the Cotto win wasn't questionable among his best wins. I'll take Golovkin's dominance in that same period.

[BM dnobagaV]

HAHAH yeah like how pac used to always have catchweights also. catchweight manny.

Can you ever not mention Manny Pacquiao? Insane obsession you have.

[Nay_Sayer]

Alvarez has the better resume. Period, end of story...

[boliodogs]

As usual you have pound for pound mixed up with resume. Your not asking us who we think is better pound for pound. You are just asking us who has the better resume. Pound for pound isn't resume. Resume is his past from the day he turned pro. Pound for pound is how good you think he is right now for his weight based on his last couple of fights not based on what he did years ago. If you go by resume then Canelo is forever stuck with his poor fight against Mayweather. Could Mayweather still beat today's Canelo? I don't think so.

[BrometheusBob.]

Debatable now, won't be when GGG smashes Jacobs in a few rounds

I voted GGG

[Robbie Barrett]

Based on who they've beaten in the past few years, who do you have ranked higher on the P4P List right now?

ESPN and The Ring both have GGG ranked higher while BoxRec has Canelo higher.

Canelo- beat Cotto, Khan, Smith, Kirkland, Angulo, Lara, Trout.

Golovkin- beat Lemieux, Brook, Murray, Geale, Rubio, Macklin, Stevens.

Canelo has arguably fought the better competition, but Golovkin has 17 title defenses and 23 consecutive KOs.

Who should be higher P4P?

Based on who they beat it's impossible to have Golovkin higher IMO.

[Real King Kong]

It's funny how p4p arguments always revert to comparing resumes.
They're roughly the same size...if they fight, i think ggg would win. P4p as a concept is, who would win if the fighters were the same size...well in this case they are. Why all the resume talk?