Joe Calzaghe vs James Toney at 168 who wins?

[Thraxox]

Prime Calzaghe vs Toney fantasy match up in the bag.

[Robbie Barrett]

While Calzaghe has his head down slapping like a crazy girl Toney counters with an uppercut that puts him to sleep.

[Cheeko12]

Toney by murder way to slick for calzaghe

[lparm]

Calzaghe by wide decision.

Toney couldn't handle RJJs speed and Joe was just as fast but with more power. Too easy.

[Lester Tutor]

Toney by decision. "Prime," man Calzaghe don't want that across the pond work at 168.

[DeLorean]

JT by late stoppage.

[DeLorean]

Calzaghe by wide decision.

Toney couldn't handle RJJs speed and Joe was just as fast but with more power. Too easy.

1994 Roy Jones (age 25) cannot be compared to 2008 Roy Jones (age 39)... Calzaghe would get b*tch slapped and embarrassed by prime Roy. . no shame in that loss for JT.

Joe was never "just as fast" as prime Roy..never.

[lparm]

1994 Roy Jones (age 25) cannot be compared to 2008 Roy Jones (age 39)... Calzaghe would get b*tch slapped and embarrassed by prime Roy. . no shame in that loss for JT.

Joe was never "just as fast" as prime Roy..never.

Joe was well past it when he schooled a near prime Roy remember that.

[Lester Tutor]

Joe was well past it when he schooled a near prime Roy remember that.

I see that sourkism my nism

[Kigali]

Joe was well past it when he schooled a near prime Roy remember that.

Jones had been knocked COLD.....twice.....that is not near prime.

Toney does horrible things to Joe....horrible things.

Slappy Joe actually fought the LOSER of an elimination bout


There is an entire Wing dedicated to Joe Calzhage in the Coward's hall of Fame.