Brook beats the **** out of everyone on that list. The win against porter is better than every name on there except for manny. Mosley was already done and past it. He beat an undefeated champ in his prime. Porter > ortiz,guerrero,baldomir,maidana,judah,and hatton.
PTI....
brook is a quality guy.....without the quality resume. you might be right about brook being able to beat those who may beat. we will never know. has brook ever cracked the p4p list ?
and dont say p4p list dont mean shlt. if brook was ranked #1, brook fans wouldnt stop making threads about it. may actually beat the people brook fans say would be no problem for brook.
may has proved himself. he doesnt need hypothetical fights. cant say that about brook.
The 20 lbs lighter, weight drained DLH that fought Pacquiao is exactly the same as the one that fought Floyd.
Nah, they definitely weren't. Floyd gets credit for his win, Manny doesn't. Yes, ODLH was considered "past it" for both fights, but he was waaaay past it for the Manny fight, he was just fringe over the hill for Floyd. Night and day difference. No one was begging Oscar to retire around the Floyd fight. On the other hand, Many people thought Oscar was done before the Manny fight was even a rumor.
Da Pimper, gatica, HandsofIron, satiev1, Kazakh Boxing, KING Khan, ////, TheNotoriousOne, Freedom all of these posters should never be taken seriously if they think GGG has a better win than Floyd's win over ODH, even though ODH wasn't prime.
That list is a who's who of posters I wasn't taking seriously already
you know times are desperate when 3g groupies say brook was a quality win. 3g cracking brooks face isnt even on may vs hatton level.
You're right. Brook is a bum. An absolute tomatoe can. Guerrero, berto, ortiz and the great maidana all beat him easily. De la hoya on ******* also beats brook. Marquez who got outboxed by bradley will outbox brook as well. The 5 4 midget hatton who's a 140 lber would run over brook as well.
Ortiz, guerrero, hatton, madiana,berto, de la hoya at his end is a murderous row of opposition. Anyone must be crazy to think brook can stand a chance at those future all time greats.
When did Floyd beat someone like prime Sugar Leonard?
I didn't disagree, just don't see the point of you bringing it up. Almost no one in the sport's history has a win that good... ok and? Does that counter the point of this thread in any way, shape, or form? Is it even relevant to the ongoing discussion?
Comment