Boxingscene.com's NSB 2016 Fighter of the Year

[Jamie harris]

I think a top 10 bigjavi. Idiot

[Humean]

Jezreel Corrales will deserve to be a voting option if he manages to defeat Uchiyama again on the 31st.

[bigjavi973]

Jezreel Corrales will deserve to be a voting option if he manages to defeat Uchiyama again on the 31st.

ok guys I was gonna put the poll up on wednesday... but do ya wanna wait till this fight?
What do ya say? I would like everyones input that way we can make a good decision on this.

[BrometheusBob.]

ok guys I was gonna put the poll up on wednesday... but do ya wanna wait till this fight?
What do ya say? I would like everyones input that way we can make a good decision on this.

Yeah, might as well wait I think.

[BrometheusBob.]

So what do ya say?

Should we have a top 5 or a top 10?

Terence Crawford
Carl Frampton
Roman Gonzalez
Vasyl Lomachenko
Manny Pacquiao
Joe Smith Jr.
Andre Ward

Usyk, Charlo, Corrales, Yamanaka, Kovalev are outsiders that could be added in

No reason it has to be 5 or 10 necessarily tho...

[SUBZER0ED]

ima nominate Joe Smith Jr.

Wasn't supposed to win any of those fights... and did in IMPRESSIVE fashion.

I can agree with that. Smith was a virtual unknown, who KO'd Fonfara in one round, and KO'd an old but very capable Hopkins. He's also an everyday blue collar guy, who puts in the work and gets the job done. This kid's going places.

[Humean]

ok guys I was gonna put the poll up on wednesday... but do ya wanna wait till this fight?
What do ya say? I would like everyones input that way we can make a good decision on this.

Yeah I think you should wait.

[Philligan]

Lomachenko for me. He got stoppage victories against a rugged veteran and a top talent and his stature probably grew more than any other fighter's this year

Frampton beat two better names, but his performances weren't dominant

I do second this, I went into this year barely knowing who Lomo is now I vote him #1 P4P hands down

[Pigeons]

Terence Crawford
Carl Frampton
Roman Gonzalez
Vasyl Lomachenko
Manny Pacquiao
Joe Smith Jr.
Andre Ward

Usyk, Charlo, Corrales, Yamanaka, Kovalev are outsiders that could be added in

No reason it has to be 5 or 10 necessarily tho...

No way on Kovalev. You don't win Fighter of the Year by losing fights. Replace Kovalev with Gassiev and you have 12 that deserve at least an honorable mention. I think Boxing Scene's polls allow a maximum of 10 though. In addition to the top 7, add Usyk, Charlo, and Corrales if he wins again, otherwise Yamanaka.

[BrometheusBob.]

No way on Kovalev. You don't win Fighter of the Year by losing fights. Replace Kovalev with Gassiev and you have 12 that deserve at least an honorable mention. I think Boxing Scene's polls allow a maximum of 10 though. In addition to the top 7, add Usyk, Charlo, and Corrales if he wins again, otherwise Yamanaka.

I'm only reporting what people have been saying in the thread

I wouldn't put Kovalev in either