My P4P top 5 (with reasons)

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Banko Villas
    Interim Champion
    • Oct 2016
    • 642
    • 62
    • 1
    • 7,118

    #1

    My P4P top 5 (with reasons)

    1: Andre Ward
    Ward has not lost a boxing match since he was 12 years old. He won gold at the Olympic Games in Athens, 2004, and he is undefeated as a professional, with a record of 31-0. At 168lbs, he won the Super Six Tournament and defeated popular quality opponents like Froch, Kessler, Abraham, etc. He lated moved up to 175lbs and defeated Kovalev, the undefeated king of the division, in a close fight. Ward has a lot of haters, but it would be unfair to not have him as the P4P number 1. His accomplishments are just insane.

    2: Roman Gonzalez
    46(38)-0. His record is not just great quantity-wise, but also quality-wise, with good wins like Cuadras and Estrada. His accomplishments are not on par with Ward's, but to have anyone other than Ward above him would just feel wrong. Gonzalez deserves to be the P4P number 2.

    3: Sergey Kovalev
    Kovalev has lethal power, which sadly cost one of his opponents his life. He punches extremely hard and while he does not have the most impressive wins in the world, it is still very impressive how he could dominate fighters like Hopkins (past it), Cleverly, Agnew, Pascal (past it), etc., and while he did lose to Ward, he gave him the hardest fight of his career and a lot of people even think that Kovalev won the fight. I disagree on that, but we can probably all agree that a rematch would be awesome. Until (and if) Kovalev defeats Ward (or Stevenson), then he deserves a nice spot as the P4P number 3.

    4: Vasyl Lomachenko
    Yeah, people has been poking a lot of fun at his loss to Salido, but there certainly was a lot of controversy during that match. In only 8 professional fights, Lomachenko has already defeated talented opponents like Walters, Russell Jr and Tatakhun, due to his insane skills and speed. As an amateur, he had an amazing record of 396-1 and won gold at the Olympic Games (twice), the world championship (twice) and the European championship. While Lomachenko is not yet as profesionally tested as Ward, Gonzalez or Kovalev, he certainly looks worthy of the P4P number 4 to me.

    5: Terrence Crawford
    Crawford is undefeated in 29 matches and possess both power, speed, stamina, offensive skills and defensive skills. He's a very solid and balanced fighter and has two impressive wins against Gamboa and Postol, both undefeated and respected fighters at the time he fought them. I don't think Crawford's best win (Postol) is better than Lomachenko's best win (Walters), which is the only thing keeping me from putting Crawford above Lomachenko, but their spots could easily change at any moment. Crawford fits as the P4P number 5.

    Notable mentions: Pacquiao (but past it), Golovkin (but his best win is Brook), Canelo (but he needs to move up), Fury (but he is too inactive).
    Last edited by Banko Villas; 11-30-2016, 08:23 PM.
  • Banko Villas
    Interim Champion
    • Oct 2016
    • 642
    • 62
    • 1
    • 7,118

    #2
    A worthy mention should also go to Lara, who conquered both Canelo, Trout and Williams.

    Comment

    • boliodogs
      Undisputed Champion
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • May 2008
      • 33358
      • 824
      • 1,782
      • 309,589

      #3
      Originally posted by Banko Villas
      A worthy mention should also go to Lara, who conquered both Canelo, Trout and Williams.
      Canelo damn near chased him out of the ring. Every poll I've seen on Canelo vs. Lara had Canelo the winner. Some Lara lovers might have him the winner but he only won the foot race. He lost the fight.

      Comment

      • Godsfly
        mental hospital toughness
        • Aug 2012
        • 4951
        • 384
        • 68
        • 22,498

        #4
        i agree with everything you said but one.......Crawford win against postol was most certainly better then walters.

        the problem is crawford is a bit underrated around here........

        Comment

        • UNBIASED BOXING
          NSB APESTA
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • May 2015
          • 2832
          • 125
          • 4
          • 26,180

          #5
          Originally posted by Godsfly
          i agree with everything you said but one.......Crawford win against postol was most certainly better then walters.

          the problem is crawford is a bit underrated around here........
          Lol, what? No. Walter's is a better name than Postal easily.

          Comment

          • boliodogs
            Undisputed Champion
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • May 2008
            • 33358
            • 824
            • 1,782
            • 309,589

            #6
            It's your list to arrange as you please. Since I thought Kovalev was a close but clear winner Ward isn't any higher than 6th on my list. GGG remains my number 1 until he loses a fight. Kovalev is my number 2,Gonzalez is 3rd, Loma is 4th and Canelo is 5th. That's my top 5 and I'm sticking to it for now. It's not against the law for GGG to remain at 160 and Canelo to remain at 154. I think they are the best in the world at their chosen weight class, and to me that is what PFP is all about. If no one in the world your weight can beat you then you must be pretty damn good pound for pound. Who can beat Loma at 130? Nobody. Who can beat GGG at 160? Nobody. Who can beat Canelo at 154? Nobody. Who can beat Ward at 175? In my opinion and the opinion of 75% of the media Kovalev just beat him.

            Comment

            • Banko Villas
              Interim Champion
              • Oct 2016
              • 642
              • 62
              • 1
              • 7,118

              #7
              Originally posted by boliodogs
              It's your list to arrange as you please. Since I thought Kovalev was a close but clear winner Ward isn't any higher than 6th on my list. GGG remains my number 1 until he loses a fight. Kovalev is my number 2,Gonzalez is 3rd, Loma is 4th and Canelo is 5th. That's my top 5 and I'm sticking to it for now. It's not against the law for GGG to remain at 160 and Canelo to remain at 154. I think they are the best in the world at their chosen weight class, and to me that is what PFP is all about. If no one in the world your weight can beat you then you must be pretty damn good pound for pound. Who can beat Loma at 130? Nobody. Who can beat GGG at 160? Nobody. Who can beat Canelo at 154? Nobody. Who can beat Ward at 175? In my opinion and the opinion of 75% of the media Kovalev just beat him.
              Dude, your top 5 is only white fighters... Be fair. It's an international sport.

              Comment

              • Godsfly
                mental hospital toughness
                • Aug 2012
                • 4951
                • 384
                • 68
                • 22,498

                #8
                Originally posted by SniXSniPe
                Lol, what? No. Walter's is a better name than Postal easily.
                explain..how so?

                walters best wins were against guys who moved up and were way past their best (vic & donaire)


                explain........

                Comment

                • Banko Villas
                  Interim Champion
                  • Oct 2016
                  • 642
                  • 62
                  • 1
                  • 7,118

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Godsfly
                  explain..how so?

                  walters best wins were against guys who moved up and were way past their best (vic & donaire)


                  explain........
                  Walters defeated Sosa, who defeated Fortuna. End of discussion. Walters got a much better resume than Postol.
                  Last edited by Banko Villas; 11-30-2016, 09:56 PM.

                  Comment

                  • .:: JSFD26 ::.
                    Brawski
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Mar 2012
                    • 33329
                    • 725
                    • 432
                    • 44,762

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Banko Villas
                    Walters defeated Marriaga, who defeated Fortuna. End of discussion. Walters got a much better resume than Postol.
                    Say what now? Come again.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP