Where do you rank Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather?

[R_Walken]

ODLH is one of Pacquiao's best wins...?

Besides the point, Manny fought a fresher JMM, a fresher Cotto, and stopped Oscar.

Should we also factor in that he was most likely juiced to the Gilles for at least a couple of those fights you mentioned

How can you have manny Top 5 and have Fliyd not cracking the top 10 that's ******ed especially when he fought he man and won 9-10 rounds. I don't care how you a rank fighter Mayweather proved he is better, If you have Manny ranked higher your just a biased bitter c.unt

I hate ranking fighters from different eras. Because the sport was too different but I'll say of their era

Floyd is #1
Manny is #2

[boxinggod101]

I think Floyd is top 10 and Manny a top 20. I have to rank Floyd higher ATG. Im not fan of his but his greatness is undeniable. 2 ATGs that got bashed but groupies, but hey, if you dont have any hater than ur not that great...

[Thraxox]

Its my opinion, thats how so. Neither one of them would have done half of what they did when there was one champion per division. People are too flippant about all time greatness. I could write a novel on why they arent in the top twenty but it would be a waste of my time. They were incredible fighters and I loved watching them both, Ill leave it at that.

Touche yeah I agree both are great fighters.

[Thraxox]

Should we also factor in that he was most likely juiced to the Gilles for at least a couple of those fights you mentioned

How can you have manny Top 5 and have Fliyd not cracking the top 10 that's ******ed especially when he fought he man and won 9-10 rounds. I don't care how you a rank fighter Mayweather proved he is better, If you have Manny ranked higher your just a biased bitter c.unt

I hate ranking fighters from different eras. Because the sport was too different but I'll say of their era

Floyd is #1
Manny is #2

Wins over Marco Antionio Barrera,Erik Morales and Juan Manuel Marquez at their best weight class disagrees.

[R_Walken]

Wins over Marco Antionio Barrera,Erik Morales and Juan Manuel Marquez at their best weight class disagrees.

Cool , and Floyds second half of their career absolutely murders Pacs , Floyd would have beat the living sh.it out Barrera & Moreales. Plus you know he beat Manny

There no one besides maybe Duran on a mythical ATG list that you can place higher then another fighter who he clearly lost too and didn't avenge it. It's like you going to put Foreman over Ali, Hearns/Hagler over Leonard

Just accept reality man Floyds higher All time then Manny

[nubianpiye]

Floyd top 10 Pac top 30

[Flash13]

Cool , and Floyds second half of their career absolutely murders Pacs , Floyd would have beat the living sh.it out Barrera & Moreales. Plus you know he beat Manny

There no one besides maybe Duran on a mythical ATG list that you can place higher then another fighter who he clearly lost too and didn't avenge it. It's like you going to put Foreman over Ali, Hearns/Hagler over Leonard

Just accept reality man Floyds higher All time then Manny

Wait what? Floyd's first half is where his résumé is... What wins are you talking about?

[LoadedWraps]

My Top 10 is (In no Particular Order):

Sugar Ray Robinson
Henry Armstrong
Muhammad Ali
Sugar Ray Leonard
Manny Pacquiao
Willie Pep
Roy Jones
Mike Tyson
Joe Louis
Roberto Duran
Julio Cesar Chavez

I got Pacquiao inside top 10 and I got Floyd inside the lower top 15 like 11-13, Yours guys? Discuss!

[R_Walken]

Wait what? Floyd's first half is where his résumé is... What wins are you talking about?

I'm just saying if you broke their careers into 2 parts both started 95-96 and the fought till 2016 so say you break it up into first and second halves for each fighter 96ish to 06ish and you Manny beating Moreales, Barrera & Marquez multiple times trumps Mayweather beating Genaro, Castillo & Corrales

What they did in the second part from 07-16. MAYWEATHERS RESUMES MURKS Pacs.nManny best win in the second half is Cotto which he was most likely juiced to the **** for. He may have beat Hatton, Mosely, Oscar more convincingly but Maywesther beat them first. Margarito was on the decline, Marquez 3 he should have lost, Bradley (great name on the CV ) the rest are 2nd & third tier names

Mayweather beat Mosley, Hatton and Oscar first. He basically shut out Manny biggest rival Marquez, Cotto, Shut out Canelo and his 2nd tier names are light years above Mannys ( Ortiz, Guerrero,Berto, Maidana ) and trump ( Algieri, Rios) did I mention that Floyd also beat Manny comfortably

[daggum]

I'm just saying if you broke their careers into 2 parts both started 95-96 and the fought till 2016 so say you break it up into first and second halves for each fighter 96ish to 06ish and you Manny beating Moreales, Barrera & Marquez multiple times trumps Mayweather beating Genaro, Castillo & Corrales

What they did in the second part from 07-16. MAYWEATHERS RESUMES MURKS Pacs.nManny best win in the second half is Cotto which he was most likely juiced to the **** for. He may have beat Hatton, Mosely, Oscar more convincingly but Maywesther beat them first. Margarito was on the decline, Marquez 3 he should have lost, Bradley (great name on the CV ) the rest are 2nd & third tier names

Mayweather beat Mosley, Hatton and Oscar first. He basically shut out Manny biggest rival Marquez, Cotto, Shut out Canelo and his 2nd tier names are light years above Mannys ( Ortiz, Guerrero,Berto, Maidana ) and trump ( Algieri, Rios) did I mention that Floyd also beat Manny comfortably

no because manny beat floyd. watch the vids. he landed more, landed cleaner, had better defense on top of being the ring general and forcing floyd to hold and bend over constantly to keep up. maybe the rest of his resume is better but head to head pac is better.