Where do you rank Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather?

[Thraxox]

My Top 10 is (In no Particular Order):

Sugar Ray Robinson
Henry Armstrong
Muhammad Ali
Sugar Ray Leonard
Manny Pacquiao
Willie Pep
Roy Jones
Mike Tyson
Joe Louis
Roberto Duran
Julio Cesar Chavez

I got Pacquiao inside top 10 and I got Floyd inside the lower top 15 like 11-13, Yours guys? Discuss!

[PAC-BOY]

My Top 10 is (In no Particular Order):

Sugar Ray Robinson
Henry Armstrong
Muhammad Ali
Sugar Ray Leonard
Manny Pacquiao
Willie Pep
Roy Jones
Mike Tyson
Joe Louis
Roberto Duran
Julio Cesar Chavez

I got Pacquiao inside top 10 and I got Floyd inside the lower top 15 like 11-13, Yours guys? Discuss!

Good list. Roberto Duran and Julio Cesar Chavez could go up on that list a little bit. Maybe flip with Roy and Mike. Pep and Manny could switch and it would still be ok or stay. All great fighters that did so much for boxing.

[Thraxox]

Good list. Roberto Duran and Julio Cesar Chavez could go up on that list a little bit. Maybe flip with Roy and Mike. Pep and Manny could switch and it would still be ok or stay. All great fighters that did so much for boxing.

It has no particular order, I wwas just writing the fighters in my top 10 but I never rank them.

[PAC-BOY]

It has no particular order, I wwas just writing the fighters in my top 10 but I never rank them.

lol welll damn....the order was pretty ***ing good.

[Sun_Tzu]

Neither one of them are in the top 20.

[Sadiqkingofko]

Mayweather is top 10, Pacquaio maybe top 25, but how the **** can your rank Pacquaio higher than Mayweather
Pacquaio's best wins Marquez, De La Hoya, and Cotto
Mayweather beat Marquez easier, He beat a bigger De La Hoya, and he beat a bigger Cotto
And plus they fought and Mayweather won

[Sadiqkingofko]

And I'm not sure how you can have Tyson top 10, Tyson wouldn't be a top 10 heavyweight

[BM dnobagaV]

Mayweather is top 10, Pacquaio maybe top 25, but how the **** can your rank Pacquaio higher than Mayweather
Pacquaio's best wins Marquez, De La Hoya, and Cotto
Mayweather beat Marquez easier, He beat a bigger De La Hoya, and he beat a bigger Cotto
And plus they fought and Mayweather won

ODLH is one of Pacquiao's best wins...?

Besides the point, Manny fought a fresher JMM, a fresher Cotto, and stopped Oscar.

[Thraxox]

Neither one of them are in the top 20.

How so can neither be top 20? WE can argue that neither can be top 10 but that is a different thing. Pacquiao did what none did before moving up in 12 weight classes while being a champion in eight different weight class while being the lineal in five different weight classes, fought in one of the most competetive featherweight eras in boxing history all awhile beating the three mexican legends along with others in his resume, how can that not be top 20 Material?

Floyd also, great resume, moved up in five weight classes, fought in a great era of welterweights and have very good people oin his resume while being a lineal champ in 4 weight classes and also defending his belt ten times, how can that not be top 20 material?

[Sun_Tzu]

How so can neither be top 20? WE can argue that neither can be top 10 but that is a different thing. Pacquiao did what none did before moving up in 12 weight classes while being a champion in eight different weight class while being the lineal in five different weight classes, fought in one of the most competetive featherweight eras in boxing history all awhile beating the three mexican legends along with others in his resume, how can that not be top 20 Material?

Floyd also, great resume, moved up in five weight classes, fought in a great era of welterweights and have very good people oin his resume while being a lineal champ in 4 weight classes and also defending his belt ten times, how can that not be top 20 material?

Its my opinion, thats how so. Neither one of them would have done half of what they did when there was one champion per division. People are too flippant about all time greatness. I could write a novel on why they arent in the top twenty but it would be a waste of my time. They were incredible fighters and I loved watching them both, Ill leave it at that.