Is The Ring Magazine P4P Top 10 Rankings a Joke?

[pesticid]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ring_magazine_Pound_for_Pound

Roman at # 1 and GGG at # 3, we have Frampton and Vasyl there too?

No Pacquaio, no Wlad, no Danny Garcia, no Adonis Stevenson but Roman, GGG, Frampton and Vasyl there?

I mean who has GGG beat to get there? Who has Vasyl beat there to get there? Roman, ok a few good wins but number 1?

Pacman loses to Floyd narrowly and is off the list? Wlad loses one fight after how many years of dominance and he's gone? I don't like Dany Garcia but he's got one of the best resumes in boxing but you have Frampton instead?

[i got the keys]

Golovkin should be lower

[R-C]

Only because you disagree doesn't mean that the list is a joke, saying that, every P4P list is just an opinion

[pesticid]

Roman at # 1 just shows you how many hipsters and nerds there are in boxing

[Canelo and GGG]

It is A joke like allways

[W1LL]

Is the RING still owned by GBP? I stopped reading after that.

[Citizen Koba]

Roman at # 1 just shows you how many hipsters and nerds there are in boxing

Show me a demonstrably accurate way of determining who would be the best if all the guys were the same weight. In fact just a precise definition of what exactly P4P means would be a good start.

Pointless, subjective bull**** is all it is, so there really is no point at all in saying this list or that list is 'wrong' cos there is no 'right' and 'wrong' here, just different opinions.

[frantic fighter]

Roman at # 1 just shows you how many hipsters and nerds there are in boxing

This, it's comical how afraid of looking dumb people are. HBO, spun this web and everybody were racing each other to jump in it. It's ridiculous to be honest.

[KingHippo]

Garcia should definitely be there.

[1hourRun]

Roman at # 1 just shows you how many hipsters and nerds there are in boxing

So whos your #1.? Kovalev? A guy that is almost 34 years old : best wins came in just three years ago fighting top talent and elite I repeat THREE YEARS AGO...best wins are a faded Pascal, Euro-bum Nathan Cleverly and a active 50+ year old HOF? or let me guess Ward? the guy is nice but he hasnt had a meaningful fight in over five years! the guys he beat are retired! Abraham I think hes the best win and could be still fighting....But Chocolatito has been fighting at the elite level since 2008 vs. Younger talent that are still champions! even Takayama that he beat in 2009 has been in the top ten @ miniweight for almost a decade...Juan Estrada is P4P , Yagashi was Lineal , Cuadras was primed undefeated # 1- 2 at a higher weight.....thats just a sample -- I dont got time today to go over this with you guys AGAIN.