I would like your top ten fighters at 154lb(in order)

[i got the keys]

Canelo
Andrade
Lara
Trout
Charlo (the better one)
Julian Williams
Cotto

Top 7

[The Smash]

Canelo/Andrade
One of those Charlos in any order
Lara

It's a very top heavy division but none of the top guys are fighting each other.

They will.

If there's one thing we know about Lara, it's he fights everyone.

[Eastcoast]

That's a respectable list but i think herd could beat half that list easily..........

Maybe, but he needs to get active to prove it.

[Mammoth]

I bet even the ******ed Charlo brother could beat Lubin

[Sadiqkingofko]

1. C. Alvarez 48-1-1(34) WBO
2. E. Lara 23-2-2(13) WBA (Super), IBO
3. Jermall Charlo 24-0(18) IBF
4. M. Cotto 40-5(33)
5. Jermell Charlo 28-0(13) WBC
6. D. Andrade 22-0(15)
7. V. Martirosyan 36-3-1(21)
8. J. Williams 22-0-1(14) WBC Americas
9. L. Smith 23-1-1(13)
10. A. Trout 30-3(17)

[Mammoth]

Holy man Lubin sucks

[boliodogs]

!st Canelo if he stays at that weight. 2nd Andrade, 3rd Lara, 4th Jermall Charlo 5th Cotto 6th Vanes 7th Trout 8th Julian Williams, 9th Jermell Charlo, 10th Liam Smith.

[Dip_Slide]

Lara
J Rock
Andrade (needs to be more active)
Trout?


I don't think highly of the Charlos to be honest.

How can you rank Trout higher than Jermall Charlo when Charlo beat Trout?

Jermell has Rosado, Martirosyan and John Jackson on his resume, not so great but not worse than Andrade's or J rock's to be honest.

I'd rank the current 154 pounders like this:

Canelo (beat Lara)
Lara
Andrade
The Charlos are about even and very close to Andrade
Trout
Cotto
J rock
Martirosyan
Culcay.

[Canelo and GGG]

1.Alvarez
2.Lara
3.Andrade
4.bigger Charlo
5.J Rock
6Trout
7.Veins
8.Cotto
9.Smaller Charlo
10.Culcay
Thats it i think,With Alvarez going up i see a Lara-Andrade or Andrade-Bigger Charlo fight for 1st spot,if he win with J-Rock ofc.

[Citizen Koba]

I'm not going to do this right but...
Canelo
Lara
Andrade
Jermell
JRoc
Jermall
Trout
Cotto

Brook there yet?

I think Brook might have a bright future at 154 but erm... he needs to actually fight there first. Andrade has looked the goods so far but what sticks in my mind - perhaps unfairly - is the work that Vanes gave him.
Funny division 154 - there's a lot of decent guys, but not really a lot to split 'em. My feeling is that if you ran a Round Robin 3 times you could well end up with a different winner each time.

Canelo might be a little out in front right now, but his performances against Lara and Trout don't tell me he's in a different league. Lara is perhaps most proven but just doesn't always do what he needs to ... Rigo he ain't. Then to my eyes it's Andrade, Jermell, Jermall, probably J Roc, (though I'd like to see him in with better comp)... yeah, actually your list is pretty good.

I'm not quite sure where Cotto belongs but even though he never did much at JMW he probably deserves to be above unproven guys like Lubin. Vanes, Figueroa or Soro probably slot in somewhere at the bottom of a top 10 too.

Trout? Hmm. Yeah. I just never thought he was all that, capable, sure but never really top shelf. Thing is I can't fairly put him below Cotto, so yeah, guess he's in too at the bottom end.