Is there any middleweight in history who could go toe to toe with GGG and beat him?

[b00g13man]

Wow. This is a serious question? Horrible, horrible poster.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Toney with the gift wins over Nunn, Tiberi, Reggie Johnson, the guy who lost twice to Montell Griffin the guy who has been protected all his career?
The guy who had no discipline to train and the guy who's prime was whenever fanboys of his decide to be his 'prime' the illustrious word with Toney that can mean one fight but the next 5 fights forget them they don't count but the fight after that one counts.... Embarrassing!

Toney lost to absolute bums in his prime.

Bernard lost to absolute bums in his prime.

Hagler lost to absolute bums.

Mcclellan lost to absolute bums.



Ggg is undefeated in his prime. There is simple no blue print. All championship fights ended via stoppage.

James Tony got outboxed by a green Montell Griffin twice. just LMAO.


oh he fought sam peter doe. skills pay the bills. toney ain't beating GGG.



Tony got outboxed twice over 12 rounds by Montel Griffin. let that sink in. He got outboxed by Drake bittytiddy over 12 rounds. a 20-8 bowling alley attendant.


GGG whitewashes Toney. His feet are too slow.

Lmao,,, you fanboys are too much..


Changing the goalposts... "Toe 2 toe" war, but now wanna claim "but toney got outboxed by montel".

So is it "toe 2 toe" or is it "regular boxing"

Really doesn't matter because toney would beat his arse either way, but it's funny to see you fanboys continually move the goalposts

[M Bison]

Lmao,,, you fanboys are too much..


Changing the goalposts... "Toe 2 toe" war, but now wanna claim "but toney got outboxed by montel".

So is it "toe 2 toe" or is it "regular boxing"

Really doesn't matter because toney would beat his arse either way, but it's funny to see you fanboys continually move the goalposts

Getting beat up by Dave Tiberi in a toe-to-toe fight explain how that bodes well for James Toney?
He has the following traits
No Discipline
His prime is whenever fanboys decide it isn't a certain year, its a certain fight
He can shoulder roll a bit but he still gets hit

Dave hurt Toney and he isn't even a big puncher, imagine what someone like GGG would do to him he'd nail him to the body push him to the ropes pick him apart with precise jabs he'd either KO him or make him quit that I'm pretty sure of maybe you can have a good chin but that lack of discipline to the body when that liver gets smacked nice and hard it doesn't matter how good your chin is.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Getting beat up by Dave Tiberi in a toe-to-toe fight explain how that bodes well for James Toney?
He has the following traits
No Discipline
His prime is whenever fanboys decide it isn't a certain year, its a certain fight
He can shoulder roll a bit but he still gets hit

Dave hurt Toney and he isn't even a big puncher, imagine what someone like GGG would do to him he'd nail him to the body push him to the ropes pick him apart with precise jabs he'd either KO him or make him quit that I'm pretty sure of maybe you can have a good chin but that lack of discipline to the body when that liver gets smacked nice and hard it doesn't matter how good your chin is.

1. The Tiberi fight is a fluke

2. Does Golovkin throw 100 punches a round like Tiberi??

3. Styles make fights.. Toney would shred Golovkin

[Madison Boxing]

Lmao...

Toney abuses Golovkin...

Montel??? That's at 175 and montel was very tricky... Probably better than anyone Golovkin has faced..
And I said becaise of styles... Montel was never in range for toney to counter, Golovkin will be there all day... Montel and GGG fight nothing alike..


James toney would absolutely 100% shred and brutaliz Ggg... Styles make fights, and toney's is tailor-made to embarrass Golovkin ..

Like what is Golovkin going to do to him???. stalk forward, jab, look to lamd power punches... Lmao, toney crushes him in brutal fashion
Golovkin really gonna stop toney??? Lmao

reverse that though, is toney going to stop GGG? No chance. Toney had a chin of concrete but could he take GGG's hard shots over 12 rounds, especially to the body?

[Sugar Adam Ali]

reverse that though, is toney going to stop GGG? No chance. Toney had a chin of concrete but could he take GGG's hard shots over 12 rounds, especially to the body?

Yeah cause toney didn't go 36 rounds with mccallum (best body puncher of his era) and jirov

How many times was toney down from body shots

Lmao

[Madison Boxing]

Yeah cause toney didn't go 36 rounds with mccallum (best body puncher of his era) and jirov

How many times was toney down from body shots

Lmao

mccallum didnt hit as hard as GGG

[Madison Boxing]

1. The Tiberi fight is a fluke

2. Does Golovkin throw 100 punches a round like Tiberi??

3. Styles make fights.. Toney would shred Golovkin

ah, i see, if someone struggles against someone and disproves your point its a fluke. If GGG loses maybe i should call it a fluke too lol

[Madison Boxing]

Getting beat up by Dave Tiberi in a toe-to-toe fight explain how that bodes well for James Toney?
He has the following traits
No Discipline
His prime is whenever fanboys decide it isn't a certain year, its a certain fight
He can shoulder roll a bit but he still gets hit

Dave hurt Toney and he isn't even a big puncher, imagine what someone like GGG would do to him he'd nail him to the body push him to the ropes pick him apart with precise jabs he'd either KO him or make him quit that I'm pretty sure of maybe you can have a good chin but that lack of discipline to the body when that liver gets smacked nice and hard it doesn't matter how good your chin is.

great post, repped. These fighters from past eras always get made out to be indestructabel. Then you examine their records and they will have some really bad losses but people brush them aside. he drew to someones who was 24-11. Imagine if GGG drew to someone of that level, he would be crucified on here lol. James toney is one of my favourite fighters, love his old school attitude, but he was beatable. And as you said, not just on this thread but on many others, people just make up when peoples primes are. Guess toney wasnt in his prime when RJJ won pretty much every round against him too. or past prime when thadzi who was 28-8 beat him, although he must have rediscoverded his prime when he beat holyfield lol

[lopetego]

People need to take the rose tinted nostalgia glasses off

no MW history can go toe to toe with GGG and beat him

yes, maybe a few ATGs could outbox him and beat him on points

but nobody can outslug the Kazakh beast, who happens to be the hardest mw puncher ever with one of the greatest chins too