So two judges had brook winning 3-1

[daggum]

I had it 2-2. Brook 2nd and 3rd. He was taking heavy damage in the 4th and got seriously wobbled in the 1st.
Also, all the punch stats show Golovkin landing more, better punches with better accuracy. 3-1 brook is crazy.

he was dropped in the third. how could he win that one? it was 3-1 ggg with a knockdown in reality but yes if you ignore the things that happened it could be 3-1 brook 4-0 brook etc...anything you want.

[Luilun]

The other one had the fight 2-2

Were you scoring them same way?

I had it 2-2 being as objective as possible.

If this fight went the distance GGG would've been robbed. Canelo-like judges.

What do you think?

By looking at the fight Brook would have never made it to round 6, 7 max

[daggum]

Well that's my point. Maybe i worded it wrong. You can score alost any fight any way you want if your agenda is big enough. In my eyes there's no way he won 3 rounds simply because 1 and 3 were fairly one sided.

I thought that knockdown was legitimate actually. It wasn't a slip, nor was there any legs tangled or anything. He went backwards and lost balance from punches. That's a knockdown.

yea he got hit with a short left hook and fell on the canvas. it was no slip or push or feet tangle crap. ref just sucks. boxing of course doesn't have instant replay or anything real sports have. they could easily review something like that. they have the time, the technology, etc...but they don't have the brains.

[MDPopescu]

The other one had the fight 2-2

Were you scoring them same way?

I had it 2-2 being as objective as possible.

If this fight went the distance GGG would've been robbed. Canelo-like judges.

What do you think?

Compubox had GGG outlanding Brook in all the rounds...

GGG felt that he lost all the rounds... He said his performace was 3-4 out of 10...

[Sun_Tzu]

I had it 2-2 the first time I watched it, 3-1 Golovkin the second time I watched it. Kell landed a few good shots but he really only won the second round.

[daggum]

Where was the fight held?

In all honesty who cares what the judges
Had

Round 1 in almost 80 percent of fights is a feel out round.

There is more than 1 way to win a fight.

Brook got beat up and lost just like every other fighter GGG ever fought.
He weighed more than GGG at the weigh in and he lost.

A loss is a loss is a loss

there are 2 ways. boring clinch fest Floyd style or knockout face first brawler ggg style.

[j0zef]

he was dropped in the third. how could he win that one? it was 3-1 ggg with a knockdown in reality but yes if you ignore the things that happened it could be 3-1 brook 4-0 brook etc...anything you want.

He wasn't dropped in the 3rd. He was pushed + slipped. Everyone, including the ref and all the announcers saw a slip.

[daggum]

He wasn't dropped in the 3rd. He was pushed + slipped. Everyone, including the ref and all the announcers saw a slip.

no it was a clear knockdown. there was no push and the reason he slipped is because a left hook hit him in the head. his legs went funny because he was hit and hurt. ggg only hit him with that left. otherwise didn't touch him cept when ggg tripped while brook was falling but brook tripped on a left hook. and they are all blind. what do you expect? go to 11:55

[Redd Foxx]

I had it 2-2 as well. The overall hype seemed to be learning toward Kell and I'm not surprised to see that the judges were influenced by that. I think Kell got extra credit because people aren't used to seeing Golovkin pressured. Looking back though, Kell doesn't seem as impressive as he did on first watch.

[j0zef]

no it was a clear knockdown. there was no push and the reason he slipped is because a left hook hit him in the head. his legs went funny because he was hit and hurt. ggg only hit him with that left. otherwise didn't touch him cept when ggg tripped while brook was falling but brook tripped on a left hook. and they are all blind. what do you expect? go to 11:55

Both of those lefts barely touched him. He fell over his right foot trying to back up.

Please stop. I'm a Golovkin fan and you give all of us a bad name by saying you had it 3-1 with a KD.