Brook. Khan. Who Is The Greater Fighter?

[soul_survivor]

You make it appear as though Khan's career has that much depth, it doesn't. On top of that I'm quite confident in saying I don't see Khan getting any more notable wins, he's done.

Stop basing this on ifs, buts and maybes.

Let's look at what has happened. Khan moved straight from 135 to 140 and beat a highly regarded champ in the division, he then beat a challenger he was supposed to duck (who gave Mayweather his hardest fight in years), then he beat a guy with the longest unbeaten run in european boxing at the time and also a mandated challenger, then he went onto unify titles against a former 2 divisin world champ and undisputed, lineal welterweight champion. He also thoroughly dominated a man who would go onto hold yet another world title, which 2 fights later would have Mayweather fighting over it.

That's Khans achievements. Plus it's not just the wins but the fact that Khan thoroughly put a beating on most of those guys.

You can **** on them if you want, that's fine (sense has long since deserted people like you) but Brook hasn't even achieved a tenth of that. His best win is a guy with 2 world title fights, Brook himself has only 4 world title fights and only 2 of them (Porter and GGG) against guys recognised as genuine top 10s in the division(s).

So it amuses me that the counter argument to Khan being greater than Brook is the resume but Brooks resume is only slightly better than the average domestic fighter. Oh wait, theres also you thinking he'd beat Khan because of so many skills...that maybe so but again, thats all ifs,buts and maybes.

On cold, hard boxing facts, Brook isn't even close.

[hugh grant]

Khan might as well fight brook now. People don't rate khan as highly as brook so more to gain than lose at this point.
Khanhas better resume but people think brook beats khan
That can't go down too well for khan

[LoadedWraps]

Khan might as well fight brook now. People don't rate khan as highly as brook so more to gain than lose at this point.
Khanhas better resume but people think brook beats khan
That can't go down too well for khan

Well said.

Good post.

[LoadedWraps]

Brook will soon eclipse Khan even resume wise.

[LacedUp]

Brook will soon eclipse Khan even resume wise.

Doesn't really take a lot.

Khan doesn't have any really impressive wins outside of Maidana - in the grand scheme of things.

[LoadedWraps]

Doesn't really take a lot.

Khan doesn't have any really impressive wins outside of Maidana - in the grand scheme of things.

It's still his best win.

Just hilarious. He is boxing's whipping boy. Always chasing bigger fights than he's entititled to and gets beat by most contenders he does step up to.

[LoadedWraps]

Bump of peace.

[LacedUp]

Results are pretty conclusive.

Brook > Khan. and if Khan's gynecologist approves, then maybe we'll see it in the ring as well.

[BM dnobagaV]

Results are pretty conclusive.

Brook > Khan. and if Khan's gynecologist approves, then maybe we'll see it in the ring as well.

Better fighter you could say so simply of Khan's chin being a -10 (with the exclusion of one fight against Maidana). If he had a smidgeon of chin, he would be ahead of Brook in the skill department. Even without a chin, his resume ****s of Brook's.

You say Brook could soon eclipse Khan's resume... How? He has beaten one good fighter, been obliterated by another, and that's been his career
And heads up, the argument isn't always "quality" as comparing Khan's win over Maidana to Brook's over Porter. Khan also has a HELL of a lot more quantity to his resume. Just look at soul survivor's post above us and you'll realize that...

[KLockard23]

Brook. N*gga had four straight rounds won over GGG before the stoppage in the fifth. And as a remainder, the reason this fight has never happened is because Amir Khan keeps turning it down. He wants no part of Kell.